Re:Is fasting safe? A review of adverse events during water-...
by scottlocklin on Thursday February 28, 2019 @01:09PM
(#19273489)
That seems rather short sighted. Much of the increase in mean lifespan from 150 years ago comes from lower number of deaths at infancy (aka doctors washing their hands). You can probably attribute most of the rest to improved nutrition and antibiotics.
The philosophy behind "paleo" and various fasting regimens (as well as different modalities of physical training) is that living close to what our primate ancestors lived like is probably something like optimal. Starving yourself from time to time, something which is actually practiced by almost all agricultural societies as a form of religious devotion, is probably a good idea. The whole "3 square meals" thing is mostly a product of marketing departments rather than any scientific research.
People also died younger 150 years ago. Humans as a population are much healthier today overall—we shouldn't look to how we lived 100+ years ago for health guidance.
(I'm not necessarily disagreeing with the crux of your post, as I don't feel knowledgable enough to weigh in)