Re:To end poverty, guarantee everyone in Canada $20,000 a year.
by philwelch on Sunday November 21, 2010 @02:30AM
(#1926620)
I anticipate a lot of people would think so (which is why I called it a tradeoff no one would agree to). It would be more interesting to know why you think it's a terrible idea.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:To end poverty, guarantee everyone in Canada $20,000 a year.
by ezy on Sunday November 21, 2010 @04:15PM
(#1927897)
Well, for one, it treats poor people like criminals who need to be punished for being poor. Granted, we do that to a large degree in the US now implicitly, but this would be very explicit -- and, I feel, tremendously mean-spirited.
More practically, it removes the poor as a voice in their own governance by using what amounts to a bribe. And in practice, it would probably remove most poor people from the voting rolls, because short-term, taking the 10k or whatever to make ends meet is the rational decision over pulling a lever that may or may not have any affect on your particular situation.
I think my main objection here is that there is no real guarantee that the extra money, generally, will push people out of poverty and back into enfranchisement -- and if it doesn't work, what you've done is institutionalize bribery and legitimize an explicit oligarchy of the rich.
Re:To end poverty, guarantee everyone in Canada $20,000 a year.
by Sisyphus_of_IT on Monday November 22, 2010 @09:49AM
(#1929923)
So if you think there's "no real guarantee that the extra money, generally, will push people out of poverty", then why bother giving them extra money at all?