News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California keeps a secret list of criminal cops, but says... by kelnos on Tuesday February 26, 2019 @10:29PM (#19260615)
The difference, again, is that police are not only public servants, but also have been entrusted with a position of extreme authority (and in-the-moment life-and-death decision-making) over everyone else, which is fairly unique to their profession. We have hired them to uphold and enforce the law. If they break the law themselves, especially if they do so while abusing their trusted position as police officers, they cannot be trusted with that job.

From there the question becomes: do we trust the hiring process for police to blacklist former cops who have abused their position? Based on the article, we should not, because it mentions several officers who still have jobs despite their misdeeds.

Given that, the public not only has the right to see this data, but should absolutely demand continuous public access to this data, as the existing system is clearly not trustworthy, and requires public oversight.

And yes, feel free to consider the same policy for lawyers, doctors, teachers, or whatever. Maybe we should require personnel records for some other professions to be public, maybe not. But it seems clear to me that for police officers, this data needs to be public.

Re:California keeps a secret list of criminal cops, but says... by mirimir on Tuesday February 26, 2019 @10:34PM (#19260638)
By that argument, it's judges that we ought to be worrying about.
Re:California keeps a secret list of criminal cops, but says... by kelnos on Monday March 11, 2019 @07:04PM (#19363748)
Yes, but in a different way. A cop can shoot you on sight and in many cases get away with it, even if it wasn't justified. They have immediate life-or-death authority over people.

Judges can make a bad or corrupt ruling, but, at least until you get to SCOTUS, you always have the ability to appeal. And there's no immediacy; an incorrect decision by a judge will never leave you dead a matter of seconds later.