Analysts were generally projecting 400k cars delivered. Musk, the CEO, the ultimate insider, suddenly reveals that Tesla will sell 25% more cars than people outside expected. I think it's fair to say that if that came as a press release from the company, the mix of information certainly would have changed and people would buy the stock.
The SEC agreement was that he would pre-clear any material tweets with a lawyer. He said in a TV interview that he wouldn't get his tweets pre-cleared, and said "I want to be clear. I do not respect the SEC. I do not respect them.” And then he tweeted material information on Tesla.
I think it's pretty fair to call that contempt of court!
This is about whether or not he intentionally crossed an arbitrary line by vaguely restating previous official company statements in an unofficial manner without complying with company policy on said utterance.
It sounds like you think "contempt of court" shouldn't matter. I think it should. It's hard to have a society with rule of law if people ignore court orders, even cool people like Elon.
My guess is that the SEC's definition and the court's definition will not agree.
Before disagreeing with this, go back and read the terms of the original settlement. A lot of people are talking smack (on both sides) about things that aren't even in that agreement.
The other stuff, like about the TV interview, is evidence that he's not acting in good faith, so the court shouldn't cut him slack here - or, in the motion's words, that he "has not made a diligent or good faith effort to comply with the provision of the Court’s Final Judgment requiring pre-approval of his written communications about Tesla. Less than two months after the Court entered its Final Judgment, Musk publicly indicated that he was not serious about compliance with this provision."
The definition of materiality you provided clears him as the numbers Musk tweeted are in the their quarterly report, so nothing new was learned.
"Materiality" is weird, I agree! Matt Levine has a running line that "everything is securities fraud" these days.
To be clear, he is in contempt of the court order around materiality. In general, not matching what analysts say isn't contempt of court, of course.
> The definition of materiality you provided clears him as the numbers Musk tweeted are in the their quarterly report, so nothing new was learned.
I do not agree. The quarterly report says "our goal is to be able to produce 10,000 vehicles per week on a sustained basis. Barring unexpected challenges with Gigafactory Shanghai, we are targeting annualized Model 3 output in excess of 500,000 units sometime between Q4 of 2019 and Q2 of 2020."
The tweet said "“Tesla made 0 cars in 2011, but will make around 500k in 2019.”
Those are very, very different statements! Musk's tweet indicates dramatically higher production at the end of 2019.