News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How I Incorporated My Startup by breckognize on Saturday November 20, 2010 @12:37PM (#1924856)
I'm going to take the opposite view and suggest that this is not a good idea. While I whole-heartedly endorse bootstrapping when you can, there is a huge risk to not having a professional look at your incorporating documents, especially when there are multiple co-founders involved. That's why this is the first thing incubators like YC and AlphaLab require. Many attorneys (if you ask) will do incorporation for a flat fee (ours was $2500).

Specifically our attorney helped us with the following issues:

- What is the structure of the shareholder agreement?

- What happens if a co-founder leaves?

- Filling out the 83(b) Election Form (so that you pay capital gains taxes on the shares you're about to be issued now rather than later)

- Mutual confidentiality agreement amongst co-founders

- Proprietary rights agreement

Believe me, I know what it's like to be a starving startup. Any cash outlay is terrifying. But you must be able to separate fear from the decision making process. $2500 is not a lot of money. And if you can't bring yourself to pay that much for something as important as an attorney, are you really starting a business? Or is it just a side project that you hope will become a business? There is a serious difference.

One last thought. We (http://www.shoefitr.com) didn't incorporate until we quit our "real" jobs to go full time. This gave us time to mitigate some technology risk and get comfortable working with each other before shelling out $2500. I think that's ok too. But if you're at the full-time stage of things, consult a professional.

Re:How I Incorporated My Startup by _pius on Saturday November 20, 2010 @10:25PM (#1926185)
I was with you until this:

$2500 is not a lot of money. And if you can't bring yourself to pay that much for something as important as an attorney, are you really starting a business? Or is it just a side project that you hope will become a business? There is a serious difference.

That's a bit obnoxious ... $2500 is a fairly large chunk of money for a new business. Even on a reasonably high developer's salary, the average person would have to save aggressively for a couple months to pay that.

It's a bit heavy handed to imply that if you don't have $2500 to blow on attorneys upfront, you aren't actually starting a business. Especially when there are boilerplate documents that get you pretty damn close without you paying a dime:

http://www.goodwinfoundersworkbench.com/

Re:How I Incorporated My Startup by csmeder on Saturday November 20, 2010 @01:15PM (#1924937)
However, if your startup depends on having a merchant account, you need to incorporate before you can get the merchant account correct?

I would really like to put off incorporating but I need a merchant account so I can bill people based on their usage.

Also even PayPal let me bill people based on usage, I hear horror stories about pay pal every day.

Re:How I Incorporated My Startup by marquis on Saturday November 20, 2010 @02:17PM (#1925078)
I don't believe you need to be incorporated to have a merchant account. I've had a merchant account without incorporating (US). Get in touch with a bank directly for info on how they can help you.
Re:How I Incorporated My Startup by rprasad on Saturday November 20, 2010 @02:30PM (#1925114)
You don't need to incorporate, but you need to at least file a DBA (doing business as).
Re:How I Incorporated My Startup by csmeder on Saturday November 20, 2010 @06:41PM (#1925718)
You need to become an LLC or sole proprietor to have a DBA right? And Isn't the common advice don't become an LLC or sole proprietor if you want VC money in the future?