Because that's what the users and the customers both want. Facebook is popular and profitable BECAUSE it provides a mostly-safe (compared to eg 4chan) place to communicate, not despite that.
If people see offensive content on Facebook, but not on a competitor, then both the users and the advertisers are going to abandon Facebook for the competitor. Every company tries to give their customers what they think the customers want.
I wont even attempt to define "porn".
If I had things my way, no piece of information would be illegal. Child porn, nuclear weapon plans, whatever, I don’t care, it should all be legal.
But I accept that it’s a fringe position, though a completely tenable and consistent one. It’s all information and I think it’s ridiculous to try and censor something that only exists in the abstract.
Moreover, once you start censoring you will never be able to stop. Even though I’m sure people will do bad things with information, I believe that history has shown that the good will outweigh the bad.
Moreover, once you start censoring you will never be able to stop.
Your position become less credible. You need to argue that the censoring that is currently being proposed or being done is indeed bad for society. Or that we’d be better off without said censoring. Engaging in slippery slope style reasoning is not helpful.
Acceptance of child porn isn't tenable, that literally creates a market for rape. Sure, you may be believe markets are an unstoppable force in human nature and that suffering is inevitable, but those are just the axiomatic beliefs you've chosen to subscribe to. If you don't care about the imposition of suffering on others that these entail, are you willing to accept the same degree of insecurity for your own person?
And, as history shows, censorship waxes and wanes in every society; you certainly can stop censoring things that once were censored.
I don't think everyone having access to nuclear plans and biological weapons is tenable. Those things aren't abstract.
All societies have regulated speech. I don’t know anyone who doesn’t believe this should be so. A desire to censor some things should not be spoken of as a desire to censor everything. Such hyperbole undermines your position.
With Facebook and Google speech is easier to disseminate. It’s also way easier to target said speech. No one can be vigilant at all times in terms of checking sources and accuracy of what we see/read/watch. People are easily duped. People are easily led to believe things that are obviously false. The anti-vax movement is an example of this.
We have entered an information age unlike any other in the past. This ability to sway, target, and reach so many at scale for so little cost has implications that may cause society to re-examine the nature of free speech. If Facebook let’s the floodgates open as you say then this re-examination will come much sooner and likely be the result of outrage and thus end up hurting Facebook in the long run. Facebook would like to prevent this from happening. Hence they take steps toward mitigating the public perception of Facebook enabling bad actors.
Unfortunately, yes in various ways. But the devil is in the details. Who decides what specific ideas should be outlawed?
The politicians who write laws. Lawmakers decide what should be outlawed.
I'm not sure why people paint this process as complicated. We live in a society, that society decides what is acceptable and what is not. You are welcome to disagree with the conclusion, but it's not some shrouded mystery how we make the choices we do.
Reading between your lines here it seems like you have never tried to define what is allowed behavior and what is not and more importantly, tried to applied that to specific issues.
It's easy to all agree that pornography, hate speech etc. is bad. But what is pornography, and what is hate speech? Where do you draw the line...
now the moderators are just subjected to constant child porn or potential child porn, which, let's be honest, is still essentially the same issue re: their mental health.
That's not how social networks work.
Just blocking it yourself seems like a better solution. You dont have to be fair in what you block yourself and (surprise surprise) you dont need to watch it in the first place.
How does that work if nobody watches it, how do you know what to block?
You only have to watch it through if you have to make sure its actually gore. Which an individual different to an employee doesnt have to.
Or simply automatically collect reports and if a high enough percentage of views vs reports comes in it put it nsfw.
I'm not sure that is any different than what the article describes.
>It’s a place where employees can be fired for making just a few errors a week
As I understand it, an employee has to make sure its extremely likely that it is a murder. She is told she can pause it by the psychiatrist, not to close it. You as an individual dont need to find out. Just close it immediately if you assume its gore.
I dont think its a simple problem. It is one without an optimal solution. I just think the downsides of having the stuff around are preferable to having people ruining their mental health out of financial desperation.
I also believe that the reliability would go up with time, people are able to learn quite a lot.
I don't know what you mean by that. If you visit facebook, you don't get to pick what you see. Certainly a few seconds of a murder is going to be less than desirable.
> Certainly a few seconds of a murder is going to be less than desirable.
While not desirable, outsourcing your second every few days to some poor guy who has to watch it all day long doesnt sound like a good solution to me.
Not a popular opinion, but its not reasonable to let kids have access to the current version of the internet and childproofing it is not a viable option. A lot of the issues we currently have with the internet can be boiled down to the contradiction of kids using it and the inability to child proof it. If we think that kids shouldnt have access to everything the internet allows access to, it should be feasible to get a second child proofed one online. With the focus on it being child proofed in mind during design, the maintenance wouldnt be that bad if you focus on access control. Kids are not allowed to walk into a sex shop or a bar, they get the internet right on their phone.
I’m not sure I really understand why big companies feel it’s their job to censor the world. Just let the floodgates open: allow violence, allow porn, allow whatever else. Who cares? And maybe this might actually good for people to see. I feel like we are leaving in this outrage culture that wants to censor everything. It’s not healthy for individuals or society.