Re:John Carmack talks about Rage SD and HD, iOS, and what's ...
by pmjordan on Saturday November 20, 2010 @01:16PM
(#1924942)
In case it wasn't intentional:
Couldn't disagree more. I like keyboards on my smartphones, and GPUs fall low on the scale of needs
doesn't contradict
most of those choices are right for most people most of the time
at all.
Re:John Carmack talks about Rage SD and HD, iOS, and what's ...
by ergo98 on Saturday November 20, 2010 @01:34PM
(#1924987)
The personal example was anecdotal. The same thought process applies to many people.
The GP opines that the Jobsian "he'll choose what's right for you" model is, as you quoted, right for most people most of the time. I would say that is absolutely not correct, and the iPhone has succeeded despite that model, not because of it: Great integration, software, and branding has overcome an incredible lack of diversity and choice.
It isn't a good long-term strategy though.
Couldn't disagree more. I like keyboards on my smartphones, and GPUs fall low on the scale of needs: I use it mostly for productive or professional use. For a lot of smartphone buyers, Rage graphics just don't matter.
I would go so far as to say as people buying an iPhone are buying an iPhone; people buying an Android phone are buying a phone (or, in some cases, they're not buying an iPhone).
People buying an Android are buying a Smartphone. No they aren't buying a brand or some sort of ridiculous personal identity. As a smartphone the Android devices are a bang up option.
My personal belief is that Android handset manufacturers are participating in seppuku.
You mean the makers who have seen the platform's sales increase 1200%+ since January? I would say the metrics would say that you are completely off the mark.