Re:Ask HN/PG : Why are comments ordered like this?
by chaosmachine on Friday November 19, 2010 @10:12PM
(#1923716)
Average comment karma of the poster plays a significant role in determining comment order.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Ask HN/PG : Why are comments ordered like this?
by palish on Friday November 19, 2010 @11:09PM
(#1923819)
Yuck. I hope it's a rolling average (i.e. the average from the last 30 days). My account is 1368 days old! How the heck am I supposed to change my average in any significant way?
Re:Ask HN/PG : Why are comments ordered like this?
by zck on Friday November 19, 2010 @11:14PM
(#1923831)
The average is calculated by taking your most recent 50 comments, dropping the first five, dropping the max, and averaging the rest. Yours is currently 7.14 (it's in your profile), a very high average. For comparison, of the 100 people on the leaderboard, there are only nine with a higher average.
Re:Ask HN/PG : Why are comments ordered like this?
by AgentConundrum on Friday November 19, 2010 @11:59PM
(#1923896)
Slightly off topic, but do you have any idea how often the average is recalculated? I only ask because I've noticed that my average hasn't changed since it appeared in the top bar, yet I've doubled my total karma in the last two weeks.
Based on the formula you just gave, my average should be 3.27, but it still shows 2.55.
I realize it's a bit of a meaningless metric, but it's something I've been idly pondering for a few days.
Re:Ask HN/PG : Why are comments ordered like this?
by dwwoelfel on Saturday November 20, 2010 @12:15AM
(#1923914)
A search at searchyc.com turned up:
"There's a background process that runs every 45 seconds and picks a random loaded user to update the average of. Empirically, not more than every couple days, at best."
Re:Ask HN/PG : Why are comments ordered like this?
by nkassis on Saturday November 20, 2010 @02:33AM
(#1924069)
I must be really unlucky, mine has been the same for a few weeks.
Re:Ask HN/PG : Why are comments ordered like this?
by revorad on Saturday November 20, 2010 @08:35AM
(#1924465)
mine too
Re:Ask HN/PG : Why are comments ordered like this?
by cubicle67 on Friday November 19, 2010 @11:52PM
(#1923883)
ah, that explains why a few days ago mine dropped from 8.x to 5.07 overnight. I just assumed the algorithm had been tweaked.
Re:Ask HN/PG : Why are comments ordered like this?
by zck on Friday November 19, 2010 @11:12PM
(#1923826)
I can't find anything in the arc source to support that. Can you point me to something?
Re:Ask HN/PG : Why are comments ordered like this?
by chaosmachine on Friday November 19, 2010 @11:23PM
(#1923845)
Re:Ask HN/PG : Why are comments ordered like this?
by zck on Friday November 19, 2010 @11:36PM
(#1923858)
Ah, good. Arc 3.1 was released sometime before 2009-08-04, since those are the timestamps of my unpacked .jar file. The post you linked is about six months old.
Maybe I wasn't as confused as I thought I was.