This has been proven experimentally (by a randomized trial) to be true. When people pay more out of pocket for medicine (95% copay vs 5%), they consume 30% less medicine, but have statistically identical health outcomes.
http://www.rand.org/health/projects/hie/
The reason people consume unnecessary medicine is unknown, but the fact that they do so is not in doubt.
(I'm not even going to address your claim that "anyone who disagrees with me on the purpose of insurance are idiots".)
http://www.rand.org/health/projects/hie/documents/b_newhouse...
Newhouse also writes: "All the Experimental cost-sharing plans had a stop-loss feature that was at most $1,000 for medical spending for the entire family for a year and less for lower income families. (The $1,000 is in late 1970s dollars, which is about $3,400 in 2007 dollars if one inflates by the all-items Consumer Price Index.)"
In other words,the cap on out of pocket expenses was roughly equivalent to three or four months worth of family health insurance premiums in today's market.
Good system.
There are plenty of pragmatic problems in the current system to address arguments to. The solutions to those problems will improve people's lives without requiring anyone to adopt new political ideologies.
Please name a single attempt to replicate the RAND experiment (i.e., a randomized trial). Really, I'm waiting. I ask because I'd really love to see something more current. It would be amazingly useful.
Incidentally, you are eliding some other interesting facts the RAND experiment turned up. For the healthiest 80% of the poor, being in the 5% copay group made them less healthy. In all cases, the variation was very small. This is roughly what you'd expect in a study statistically measuring many null results - a few measures turn up non-zero purely by chance.
Similarly, if you study the affect of prayer on 30 or 40 different medical problems, you are likely to come up with 1 or 2 positives.
Yeah. Also, he's trying to make you drive an unsafe car by not paying for your Volvo. There's no reason why your employer should be involved with your health insurance. Our current system eliminates pricing signals, discourages entrepreneurship, doubly screws you if you lose your job, and means that you get to disclose personal health information to HR.
health insurance isn't insurance
Yes, and this is the source of much confusion in these discussions. Most of us would be better off with real insurance, where we pay for minor and routine services directly, and are still protected from large unexpected expenses. It's true that some people can't get real insurance because of preexisting conditions, and we should help them directly.
ps -- people who don't straightforwardly acknowledge that health insurance isn't insurance, it's group cost pooling, are idiots who should be ignored in the health care debate. It's not insurance and shouldn't be because we can tell that in certain cases people will cost a lot of money to treat. Insurance would leave them out in the cold. Societies with integrity or conscience treat people anyway. Compare to insurance -- if you build a house in a flood zone on the florida cost, you should probably be told hell no -- no company will sell you insurance. If all the women in your family get breast cancer, we should still give you health insurance for when you get breast cancer.