That's not high-deductible, it's low-benefit. A high deductible plan would have you pay out of pocket up to $5k or $10k, and then cover everything above that. I agree that a plan that caps benefits (at something less than $1 million or so) is practically worthless, because the sort of events you actually want to insure against get expensive really fast.
I have less experience shopping for group plans, but in the individual market you will die of natural causes before you find a high-deductible, high-benefit plan, let alone one without fatal loopholes.
I know a woman under 40 who had cancer, and a woman under 30 who had cancer. And I may know more, for all I know. Plus plenty of over-50s who've had cancer. And my social sphere is not all that large.
I'd have to say cancer is not really a low-probability event.
I reviewed plans with a health insurance broker in Washington state in September, who openly mocked some Regence (Blue Shield) coverage with a fifteen hundred dollar annual limit on "complex imaging", which means MRIs, CAT scans, PET scans, mammography, etc. He said, "Do you have any idea how many scans you'd get if you had cancer?", and that $1500 might cover most of the first one. If you missed that detail and got sick, you might as well not have insurance.