News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by grellas on Friday November 19, 2010 @12:53PM (#1922083)
There is no magic to working 8 hours every day or any other number for that matter.

Before the industrial revolution, most people were farmers. They got up at sunrise and typically worked long, hard days in the fields - workdays that were not circumscribed by any arbitrary time limit but rather defined by whatever it took to deal with the exigencies of each day.

The 8-hour day, as some sort of idealized goal, came about as a direct result of the industrial revolution. With people moving to cities and taking up factory work, reformers began to characterize such work situations as exploitative, particularly of children but also of adults in terms of length of hours worked in physically demanding situations. The answer for reformers lay in having governments prescribe maximum normative work periods, with anything in excess of the prescribed maximum being deemed extraordinary and warranting extraordinary compensation. Hence, in America, we eventually got the 8-hour day and the 40-hour week. (See, e.g., http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eight-hour_day for an overview).

I don't think "corporate America" has any particular stake in the 8-hour day. If anything, employers would undoubtedly want to have the power to shape the work schedules of employees in more flexible ways, especially by being able to freely demand longer work hours at normal compensation as a condition of continued employment. Of course, this would require repeal of the wage-and-hour laws that today proscribe any such thing. My point, though, is that it is those laws and not any scheme by employers that keeps the 8-hour structure in place as the normative work environment.

Bottom line: given pure freedom of contract, people could work any schedules they want and, in fact do so (that is what it means to be in business for yourself); however, given the problems arising from pure freedom of contract, the law imposes rigid limits deemed beneficial from a societal perspective on what may be expected of employees. That, I believe (and, I don't think, any other major factor), is what requires most people to work 8-hour schedules as their normative workday, at least in the U.S.

On a final note: the typical startup environment is really a throwback to the freedom of farming days because, in the earliest stages, there basically are no formal employees but rather just founders working round-the-clock like madmen for what might often be described as "below dirt wages," and, in later stages, there are large numbers of "exempt" engineers who are not subject to the overtime rules and hence who are also working insane hours - thus, not too many 8-hour days in your prototypical startup. I don't think most of the participants regard this as exploitation, probably because most of it is self-driven, i.e., most such people want to drive themselves hard in order to succeed.

Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by nostromo on Friday November 19, 2010 @02:47PM (#1922518)
Great comment. One thing I'd point out however -- you make farming sound like the hardest job one could have. Perhaps it is durring the summer. However, many northern famers used to 'hibernate' all winter. Here's a great description of the phenomenon:

> In 1900, The British Medical Journal reported that peasants of the Pskov region in northwestern Russia “adopt the economical expedient” of spending one-half of the year in sleep: “At the first fall of snow the whole family gathers round the stove, lies down, ceases to wrestle with the problems of human existence, and quietly goes to sleep. Once a day every one wakes up to eat a piece of hard bread. ... The members of the family take it in turn to watch and keep the fire alight. After six months of this reposeful existence the family wakes up, shakes itself” and “goes out to see if the grass is growing.” http://www.nytimes.com/2007/11/25/opinion/25robb.html

Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by travisjeffery on Friday November 19, 2010 @10:35PM (#1923774)
That may have happened and have been possible in 1900, but I grew up in a farming family and there is no way any farming people who wish to be profitable and have a good business do this today.

Today it's more like you have a job for year round income like hardwood flooring or whatever and then in the Summer you have 2 jobs: whatever job you have year round and then your additional farming work.

Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by maxawaytoolong on Friday November 19, 2010 @11:04PM (#1923813)
I guess it depends on what you are farming. Where I grew up the farmers grew commodity crops like wheat and soybeans and did mostly take the winter off. Sometimes they'd have a 2nd job as a pee-wee hockey coach or something like that.
Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by arethuza on Saturday November 20, 2010 @05:32AM (#1924268)
I seriously doubt anyone in rural Russia in 1900 was hibernating because there life was so easy that they could manage to sleep half the year.

The peasants in such an area were probably only a generation or so away from serfdom so their living conditions were probably pretty grim and this is north western Russia we are talking about - not exactly a region famed for its gentle winters.

Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by jseliger on Friday November 19, 2010 @01:15PM (#1922180)
Before the industrial revolution, most people were farmers.

And before they were farmers, most people were hunter-gatherers, whose work estimates range widely as measured by anthropologists and others; some may have "worked" in the sense we think of it in the neighborhood of four hours a day.

(I don't have a great citation on it, but I know I've read variations on it before, perhaps in Napoleon Chagnon's work or Robert Wright's The Moral Animal).

Still, "workdays that were not circumscribed by any arbitrary time limit but rather defined by whatever it took to deal with the exigencies of each day" is still true.

Note that many grad students and profs live similar lives -- they don't have much allocated time when they must teach, but they still have to get their work done.

Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by shortlived on Friday November 19, 2010 @04:25PM (#1922853)
> I don't think "corporate America" has any particular stake in the 8-hour day. If anything, employers would undoubtedly want to have the power to shape the work schedules of employees in more flexible ways, especially by being able to freely demand longer work hours at normal compensation as a condition of continued employment.

This is already in place at many non-startup tech companies now. There is nothing on the books stating that if you only work 40 hours/week you will be fired or demoted, but at every company I've worked for, it is known that if you want to be "in favor" with management, you best make things happen when needed.

> the typical startup environment is really a throwback to the freedom of farming days

It sounds like you are romanticizing the life of a farmer a bit here. Are you? There is a clear distinction between having to work 15 hour days and wanting to (in order to succeed).

Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by sili on Friday November 19, 2010 @01:30PM (#1922245)
Of course, this would require repeal of the wage-and-hour laws that today proscribe any such thing.

I can only imagine the fight that unions would put up to any change of this kind, justified or not.

Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by hasenj on Friday November 19, 2010 @03:30PM (#1922679)
> Before the industrial revolution, most people were farmers.

That's not really true.

OK, perhaps it was only true in Europe.

There were many other things one could be: craftsman, trader, and many other occupations.

Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by InclinedPlane on Friday November 19, 2010 @05:23PM (#1923051)
Most people were still farmers. Greater than 90% of the population had to be farmers, because if that wasn't the case the people would starve, because farming was so inefficient. While many improvements in agriculture throughout history had vastly increased the agricultural surplus and the capacity for non-farm work nevertheless the bulk of the population had been farmers. Only since the late 19th century has that changed.
Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by hasenj on Friday November 19, 2010 @05:54PM (#1923161)
> Greater than 90% of the population had to be farmers, because if that wasn't the case the people would starve

That's quite a bold statement. Do you have a source to back it up?

If that was the case, there wouldn't be such a thing as a city or a civilization.

From what I understand, most people in Europe were peasants because the ruling class wouldn't let them be anything else, not because it was the only sustainable choice economically.

Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by rfrey on Friday November 19, 2010 @09:41PM (#1923659)
Do you have a source to back it up?

1790: US Total population: 3,929,214; farmers 90% of labor force.

1840: Total US population: 17,069,453; farm population; 9,012,000 (est.); farmers 69% of labor force

http://www.agclassroom.org/gan/timeline/farmers_land.htm

Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by hasenj on Sunday November 21, 2010 @10:18PM (#1928596)
That's only in the US,this doesn't prove it was a global phenomenon.
Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by nowarninglabel on Friday November 19, 2010 @10:12PM (#1923717)
http://www.ncpa.org/pub/bg146?pg=3

That took too long to find. The data backing that up is also available in Global shift by Peter Dicken http://amzn.to/avt5eU

I didn't think the statement was bold at all, but granted I was a TA for a course on Global Food & Hunger.

Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by arethuza on Saturday November 20, 2010 @05:36AM (#1924274)
I think you are thinking about serfdom - which ended at different times (15th Century or so for what is now the UK) and a recently as 1861 in places like Russia.
Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by biotech on Friday November 19, 2010 @09:22PM (#1923626)
> Do you have a source to back it up?

It seems unreasonable to expect others to provide sources when you don't source your own information.

Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by hasenj on Friday November 19, 2010 @09:42PM (#1923660)
I'm not the one who came up with an outrageous claim.
Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by akgerber on Friday November 19, 2010 @10:46PM (#1923786)
It's pretty much at the level of common knowledge that for most of human history, the primary human occupation was food production.
Re:Why the 8 Hour Workday Doesn’t Make Sense by hasenj on Saturday November 20, 2010 @01:52AM (#1924030)
"Before the industrial revolution" is only like 150 years (or so) ago.