I'll believe pass-through HDMI when I see it. HDMI anything is a total pig's breakfast, even today -- thanks, HDCP, for not letting me plug my PERFECTLY HDCP COMPLIANT TV into my PERFECTLY HDCP COMPLIANT SCALER via DVI. It's enough to drive one to books.
Maybe, just maybe, if competitors could achieve 80% of the functionality with 20% of the buttons, then that would be something to crow about. But solving 20% of the problem isn't enough.
It just means you now have at least two remotes (one for live sports, one for digitally delivered TV shows etc.) which multiplies complexity, but Apple (or whoever) only takes credit/blame for part of the problem/solution and pretends the rest doesn't exist. It's not someone elses problem, it's my problem and Google is to their credit at least trying to solve it. Pass-through HDMI alone is a genius idea that would make my homebrew XBMC solution a great deal better.