Re:Google says Nest’s built-in mic not listed in specs was n...
by sonnyblarney on Wednesday February 20, 2019 @03:58PM
(#19211904)
Google is not going to all of a sudden start recording you in your home without your knowledge, and then say 'hey look, you signed a contract'. That would be an obvious PR disaster, not an 'I forgot disaster'.
If/when Google enables this tech, it think it will be clear enough. If not, then definitely would be time to raise a real fuss.
"There seems no good reason to me that the specification summary can't say" - I agree with you there - however, I suggest that they mighn't have even have thought of it. That would be the prudent thing to do, but again, there's no established procedure for it.
There probably was not even a legal review hint etc. because as I say, they were not using it.
So it's questionable, weird, but not nefarious.
What they will do, with your ostensible permission, with a signed T&C - is to me, far more nefarious.
I've got to disagree here: it has privacy implications because at Google's end they can issue a software update and now be monitoring all audio, and the T&C no doubt say they can be unilaterally varied without notification. That all means that Google think I accept Google snooping on me; of course I don't but in court Google lawyers would say I did, and them being in a position to do that is important.
Also, if Google can enable the mic at some point then it's likely that's a possibility for a third party (crackers), OR that Google could do it in response to a legal demand from a government.
There seems no good reason to me that the specification summary can't say "microphone - not in use yet, reserved for future applications"; with a sentence somewhere expanding on that explaining they want the ability to improve the device later and do shipped a mic because it could be useful to expand the products capabilities.
Some of us actually do read instruction books; it would no doubt get some column-inches in a positive way ("what changes might Google make").
Google know everything they make is going to get a tear-down and that mics are going to be discovered in short-shrift: it's ignorant to not anticipate that. In fact one really has to assume they knew this "issue" would come up.