Re:Show HN: Chrome Extension to See IMDB Ratings Directly on...
by selflesssieve on Tuesday February 19, 2019 @02:58PM
(#19202208)
RT has Black Panther as their #1 movie of all time. The fact is, people have learned to inherently train themselves to use certain review websites. https://www.rottentomatoes.com/top/bestofrt/
My current rules - Anything over an 8 on imbd is a must watch if over a year old. If a comedy/action movie over a 7 is fine. For less than a year old I read reviews, and decide how invested I am in watching it. Fantastic Beasts 2 tanked, but I watched it anyway and enjoyed it.
Re:Show HN: Chrome Extension to See IMDB Ratings Directly on...
by eythian on Tuesday February 19, 2019 @03:31PM
(#19202482)
Similar for me, but more forgiving. Especially for horror which I enjoy but IMDb raters don't seem to the same. In general, anything below a 6 I'll maybe reconsider, or 5 or so for horror.
Re:Show HN: Chrome Extension to See IMDB Ratings Directly on...
by darkpuma on Tuesday February 19, 2019 @02:54PM
(#19202172)
It's not so much a question of who is correct or incorrect, but rather which will be more relevant to consumers. Probably the "consumer product" reviews. Not always, but for the most part.
> Or voting some awful art house movie a 10/10 to signal that they, too, understood the high brow nuances that the groundlings could not.
I think this just speaks to a divide in movie reviews. Those critics are reviewing the movies as art, whereas many user reviews are reviewing movies as a consumer product. Neither approach is incorrect, but they have very different outcomes.