News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask YC: Do you love or hate software piracy? by 0x44 on Friday May 16, 2008 @12:31PM (#191925)
> Does anyone agree with me?

The law doesn't even agree with you. Copyright is not a natural right, it's an exchange of monopoly for the hope that your artistic achievement will advance the natural arts of our society. If the terms of that grant are onerous and society derives no benefit from it, then it is not immoral or unethical for society to revoke your monopoly.

In this case, if everyone is pirating, then it's absolutely moral for an individual to do it.

Re:Ask YC: Do you love or hate software piracy? by edw519 on Friday May 16, 2008 @02:04PM (#192046)
"The law doesn't even agree with you."

My lawyer would beg to differ with you.

"Copyright is not a natural right"

Neither is land ownership.

"In this case, if everyone is pirating, then it's absolutely moral for an individual to do it."

Thanks for the new counterargument. This one is even better than "They've already ripped me off, so I'm just getting them back." I guess I'll be using it in next month's post.

Re:Ask YC: Do you love or hate software piracy? by davidw on Friday May 16, 2008 @03:49PM (#192171)
Land is a rivalrous good, whereas most digital products are not.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rivalry_(economics)

Some information goods are excludable, but not easily, and less so with fast internet connections. This pushes them towards the category of 'public goods':

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_good

Copyright is "legislated exclusion":

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_good#Possible_solutions

Anyway, copyright is a compromise, and I agree that people should respect the law, but the law should also change to fit the facts. The Mickey Mouse copyright extenions, for example, are what might be described in technical terms as "a load of horse shit". 100 years is way too long. I think that we should look at how to rejig the compromise, without eliminating it completely, for the moment.

Re:Ask YC: Do you love or hate software piracy? by 0x44 on Friday May 16, 2008 @04:59PM (#192228)
If society declines to acknowledge the limited monopoly granted, why is it immoral for an individual within that society to also ignore the monopoly?
Re:Ask YC: Do you love or hate software piracy? by sabat on Friday May 16, 2008 @03:16PM (#192131)
"My lawyer would beg to differ with you."

The constitution doesn't agree with your lawyer.

To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries.

That established copyright. It doesn't say anything -- direct or implied -- about "property". And if you read the letters of Jefferson, you can see that the idea that an intangible item cannot be treated as property was very much on the founding fathers' minds.

Re:Ask YC: Do you love or hate software piracy? by bdr on Friday May 16, 2008 @05:53PM (#192262)
Please stop equating being legal with being moral.
Re:Ask YC: Do you love or hate software piracy? by 0x44 on Friday May 16, 2008 @08:09PM (#192339)
There is no inherent morality to the copyright monopoly as it is not a natural right. It was created foremost as a mutually beneficial arrangement between the Crown and publishers to ensure certain subjects were not published in exchange for a guaranteed monopoly on publication. In our current system, copyright is supposed to be a mutually beneficial arrangement between Society and creators to foster the useful Art in exchange for a temporary monopoly. Since the temporary nature of that monopoly has been over-stretched, effectively to the point of permanence, society (especially the digitally literate youth) has begun to disregard the compromise.