Actually that is false, as far as low doses:
>When you are asked whether there is a critical time period over which 1 rem of dose may have a greater biological impact than it might otherwise have, the answer is "No." One rem of dose is sufficiently low that whether it was delivered within one second or spread over a year or more, we would not expect any difference in biological effects.
https://hps.org/publicinformation/ate/q8325.html
(For comparison, 1 uSv = 0.1 mrem).
>The risk of cancer is caused by DNA errors. Your cells are constantly checking and repairing your DNA for mutations and damage. They can usually repair or detect a low error rate
But in this dose regime, ionization events are so rare, that they are so far apart that no cell experiences more than one. There is no variation in error rate.
"There have been numerous biological experiments conducted, with nonhuman organisms, that demonstrate that the rate at which radiation dose is delivered can affect the extent of biological response. Thus a sufficiently high dose delivered over a period of a few minutes may be expected to have a greater biological impact than the same dose spread over a year."
The only question is what constitutes a "sufficiently high" dose, due to extrapolation. See 5).
THEIR OWN POSITION PAPER on backscatter scanners recommends per-screening and per-year (time limit!) maximums FAR below the threshold that they claimed wasn't a problem in the first place -- see 8).
4) Further, the terse "no" answer looked disingenuous. The cited position paper link was broken but I tracked it down.
It appears to be "Radiation Risk in Perspective", PS010-2 (which I assume is the updated version of PS010-1).
It has nothing to say about doses over short time periods.
http://www.hps.org/hpspublications/positionstatements.html
5) The issue seems to be that there is very little data about low-dose exposures, so regulations are based on extrapolation from high-dose exposures.
See http://www.ncrponline.org/PDFs/TST_NRC%20_04-08-08.pdf (third slide)
6) What it does say is this:
"the Health Physics Society recommends against quantitative estimation of health risks below an individual dose of 5 rem in one year or a lifetime dose of 10 rem above that received from natural sources."
7) The whole point of their objection was that we lack the empirical evidence to extrapolate from high doses to low doses. Then the article you cite does exactly that. They go from saying, "we lack proof that the answer is X" to saying, "the answer is ~X".
8) The recommended standard "limits the reference effective dose delivered to the subject to 0.25 microsieverts (25 microrem) per screening. Additionally, a screening facility should not expose any individual to more than 250 microsieverts (25 millirem) reference effective dose in a year."
"Use of Ionizing Radiation for Security Screening Individuals" PS017-1
http://www.hps.org/hpspublications/positionstatements.html
How they can go from saying in the first paper, "However, below 5–10 rem (which includes occupational and environmental exposures), risks of health effects are either too small to be observed or are nonexistent" to supporting a maximum of 0.025 rem per year is entirely unclear.
Except that the Health Physics Society seems to have turned into a pro-industry spokesgroup.
The current president works for Dade Moeller, who are embroiled in a number of controversies, to put it lightly.
A lot of extremely damaging information is cited in the original link below.
""Hirsch then zeroed in on Dade Moeller’s radiation plan and on the controversial company itself, whose namesake testified back in the 1990s that money spent on cleaning up Cold War-era nuclear facilities was being wasted since there would be a cure for cancer."
Original comment:
>...How they can go from saying in the first paper, "However, below 5–10 rem (which includes occupational and environmental exposures), risks of health effects are either too small to be observed or are nonexistent" to supporting a maximum of 0.025 rem per year is entirely unclear.
Where they support that 0.025 rem/year recommendation, they explain that the point is to keep "individual doses as low as reasonably achievable (ALARA) while achieving the desired objective." (Same source, PS017-1).
And you mischarcterize their claims. HPS does not claim <5 rem doses are "not a problem" -- they said the effects are such are "either too small to be observed or nonexistent". (It does not follow that a health effect too small to be epidemologically noticable is "not a problem"). "Too small to be observed" is NOT a quantifier of significance; it is an explanation for the lack of empirical observations. That position statement (PS010-2) is a recommendation against quantiative estimation of the effects of <5 rem radiation doses, not an assertion of their absolute safety.
>It appears to be "Radiation Risk in Perspective", PS010-2 (which I assume is the updated version of PS010-1). It has nothing to say about doses over short time periods.
It does not appear to have been referenced for that purpose.
Your comment referenced it for that purpose.
Your comment about dose per unit time not mattering referenced an article which referenced their position paper which didn't support what the article said. Hence the article was simply the opinion of the author.
> (And you mischarcterize their claims. HPS does not claim <5 rem doses are "not a problem" -- they said the effects are such are "either too small to be observed or nonexistent". (It does not follow that a health effect too small to be epidemologically noticable is "not a problem").
"Nonexistent" sounds like "not a problem" to me.
"Too small to be observed" is the same. How is a problem that causes no observable effects a problem? That's the practical definition of "not a problem".
And if dose per unit time doesn't matter, then their per-screening and annual limits for these small doses wouldn't matter. They are contradicting themselves.
Further, as mentioned, they are not an independent safety group. They are an industry group for the pro-nuclear lobby. This is like relying on the Business Software Alliance (BSA, a front group for Microsoft and other large software corporations) for opinions on the harmful nature of DRM, copyright laws, etc.
My remaining concern would be that the biological effects of this particular energy regime are as-of-yet uncharacterized.
While everyone is busy losing themselves in radiation hysteria, where facts are only guessed at, the government is laughing their ass off, because everyone lost sight of the actual problem: that these machines are assumed to improve safety in the first place. The radiation scare is an enormous red herring that mainly harms the public perception of 'radiation', that wasn't too good to begin with, for all the wrong reasons.
I'll hazard a guess here and say there's close to zero probability that backscatter machines are lowering your risk of cancer.
Don't get me wrong: I love radiation. I think Cherenkov glow is the coolest thing about working in a reactor. I've handled more sources than I probably should have by this point in my life. At the same time, we should be honest that there is probably a small risk, and it is probably higher than currently stated.
We know that short-term small doses of X rays results in
increased probability of developing skin cancer.
An increase that is so minute that we don't mind the dentist or doctor X-raying us. An increase that is so minute that we would accept it, if it actually reduced our chances of dying due to a terrorist attack. The radiation is not the problem: it is the intended goal that we have no reason to believe in. We know that prolonged exposure to low-level radiation
sources increases your probability of developing skin
cancer
Do we? Not WiFi or the low-energy spectrum of the sun. What energy is 'low' in this respect?. And how long is 'prolonged exposure'? These claims are undoubtedly true for some values of the aforementioned quoted terms, but are they relevant here? Do most of the people repeating this stuff even wonder about that? Again, the problem is a slightly increased risk. But why is that increased risk a problem in the first place? I'll hazard a guess here and say there's close to zero
probability that backscatter machines are lowering your
risk of cancer.
And I agree. But the "we don't know for sure" argument is pretty shallow, when we accept certain risks on a daily basis and when we all know certainty doesn't exist and we all take aspirin to prevent a second heart-attack, even though a thousand doctors will argue with another thousand doctors about whether that actually works, all citing studies supporting their side, and the net effect is quite small even according to the side affirming it works.An increase that is so minute that we don't mind the dentist or doctor X-raying us.
Actually, we do. There are good reasons we impose strict limits on your medical X-ray exposure annually, and why you wear a lead vest or use collars to protect other tissue. There's also a good reason the radiologist stands outside the other room to press the button. Two x-rays a year is not significantly mutagenic. Fifty? Then you start getting nervous.
Not WiFi or the low-energy spectrum of the sun. What energy is 'low' in this respect?. And how long is 'prolonged exposure'
UV exposure from solar radiation is one of the biggest melanoma risks. A few orders of magnitude up the frequency scale, X rays for far shorter durations also have mutagenic effects on skin tissue. It's possible that low-energy X rays, falling in the middle of that energy range, also cause cancer. We don't know for sure yet because we don't regularly expose people to them.
(I should mention that just because the X rays are low energy does not mean their effects scale linearly. Medical X rays are well above the Compton shoulder. IIRC (not enough time to check now) they're thermalizing slowly in heavy tissues as opposed to bouncing inelastically off the surface layers. Depending on the scattering cross-section for those energies, the backscattered X rays could be more ionizing. Total conjecture... I haven't done this for a while.)
Again, the problem is a slightly increased risk. But why is that increased risk a problem in the first place?
You're absolutely right. We have no good characterization of the risk. Radiation biometrics is fucking hard. I only want to argue that our current risk statement is inaccurate and poorly understood (for instance, we don't even know the angular flux of these machines), and offer some potential reasons why the risk might be higher than currently stated.
The risk of cancer is caused by DNA errors. Your cells are constantly checking and repairing your DNA for mutations and damage. They can usually repair or detect a low error rate, like the kind you get from living at high altitude, in a house with a minor radon source, or flying on a plane. What they can't deal with as well is a sudden burst of many errors. Backscatter X-ray scanners deliver their entire dose to a tissue region in a few microseconds. That's the kind of exposure we're talking about, and it has an entirely different biological impact.