http://www.readwriteweb.com/start/never-mind-the-valley/
http://www.fastcompany.com/1699323/why-you-should-start-a-co...
The key take away (for me) isn't that one city can make or break a company but there are certain considerations to make.
Caveat A: if your company success is predicated on being inside of a known echo chamber or circulatory system of talent -- by all means consider SF/NY/etc...
Caveat B: if you need to be aligned a specific niche that has no ties to an "NFL city" -- get away as fast as you can to where that niche can best be served with the basics quality of life that will draw the talent and team you desire.
SAS software is the largest privately held software company on the planet. Yet... they started not in SF/NY... but... North Carolina?
rip needle across the record
RightNow is a public software company that was not started in SF/NY... but... Montana?
rip needle across the record
There are more. Seriously. Think about it and do the searches. Download Crunchbase and plot it...
Don't take my text for it... Just pick up your head and look around to see a world that doesn't -exclusively- fit in zip codes starting with 941xxx and 112xxx.
2. Los Angeles, Seattle, Austin and Boston specifically have a lot of angels and not a lot of great companies in my experience.
3. You will give up some cross-pollination, yes. However, you will experience less turnover and competition for talent. The best thing an up and coming startup could do in my mind right now is move to Seattle, DC or Boston.... there are so many amazing developers there who want to work at a kick-ass startup. If Twitter moved their HQ to Seattle right now they would get a flood of folks from Amazon, Microsoft, etc. to join them.
Part of the reason there is that they aren't in the Valley echo chamber. Farther you get from home, the less press you get, therefore the fewer people thinking "what a great company".
Folks in those cities are raising $250-500k at $1.5-2m valuations, where in NYC and the Bay Area/Valley we see $4-6M valuations.
You are correct that those companies get less press.... however, they just have to be creative and successful and they will get it (RedFin and Groupon and Gowalla come to mind).
Maybe you are - it doesn't come across that way.