Re:Ask HN: Please rate our startup Neetly
by mdoyle on Thursday November 18, 2010 @01:04PM
(#1918659)
Thanks for the feedback. The most common aspect about all the feedback posted so far is the understanding of the concept. It is clear to us that we need to review the homepage and the message the product communicates, and the placement or function of images or buttons. We never thought there would be comparisons to VPN's.
Re:Ask HN: Please rate our startup Neetly
by bobbywilson0 on Thursday November 18, 2010 @01:06PM
(#1918667)
Here is a little screenshot, which in my opinion does a lot for understanding what it is.
http://grab.by/grabs/fd40f157cef16b5028333e3bf9dc3923.png
The VPN is a probably a rare thing, but to tech people when you say private network, without context it is easy not to think social.
Here's why:
I think your landing page copy needs some work. Immediately when I see create your own private network, I am thinking VPN. "Socialise in groups," to me seems ambiguous, isn't socializing an inherent group activity.
In terms of design, there is low visual affordance. I am not enticed to roll over those icons, or click on the sign up button. I think "Create your own network now" is a good call to action, should be more prominant and should be followed up with a start now link or something, or get started, something to encourage the user a bit. "Sample network" shouldn't be directly next to "Create Network", it confuses what action should be taken. Sample network shouldn't be a button, just a plain link. Also that blue is far from harmonious with the rest of the color scheme you have working. The text below the icons needs more contrast with the background.
I want to see a screenshot / screencast to show me what I am getting. I still can't imagine what this thing even is.