On the other hand, a private partner can always fold, go bankrupt, etc. while the state isn't going anywhere and it's obliged by law to abide by it's commitments. So this asymmetry almost guarantees a strong survivor bias towards very bad deals for the public.
Except when everything goes exactly to plan for decades, PPPs tend to either fail or be detrimental to the public, by their innate nature. If we bring a bit of corruption into discussion in the initial tender phase, you get the full picture.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public-private_partnerships_in...
Then they leased it to a private consortium for 99 years for $3B, claiming that it was a win because it "cost" $1.5B to build. That consortium has since made a windfall charging ludicrous toll fees -- the public pays again -- privatizing the profits.
PPP is overwhelmingly a sign of a bad deal. Where politicians trying to get a short term "win" end up costing ratepayers multiples.
Btw, do you ever watch TRNN or Economic Update?
With every attempt of privatization of public services, I point out that:
* Public services are sometimes just that - they won't be profitable
* Privatization not only incentivizes skimping on services and deferring infra investment to save costs, but you now have the insult of a profit margin built into prices on often vital services. The "private sector efficiency" privatizations are sold on almost never end up aligning with the public interest
* Undoing privatization almost always costs more than was made privatizing.
Some other bad example:
Chicago selling decades of parking meter collection for pennies on the dollar
German Railways going private and the continual gutting of rural services that came along with it
Enron's market manipulation of California electric grid, causing blackouts and skyrocketing prices while they profited
I should add another important point about the 407 -- the route was chosen to be a traffic release, and an industrial corridor. Because of the very high toll roads it has become essentially an "executive" highway ($41+ one way trips), and the trucks and other traffic it was supposed to offload clog up the existing highways. The public benefit has been completely destroyed because the highway has been re-purposed for private benefit.
It is a debacle from top to bottom. But for one brief moment a government could claim a balanced budget (though they were actually $10B in the red).
Because in the US, is is not a proven model. The vast majority of public-private partnerships really end up being "public eats the costs, but private entities win all the benefits". It's gotten to the point that the mere existence of the phrase "public-private partnership" is a red flag that something corrupt is happening. (If it was a good faith effort and all above board, then it would all be done publicly in the first place).
> it saves govts. from spending large money upfront and not only ensures that private corporations finish the projects but also makes them liable for quality as they are liable for future maintenance.
Sure, but it usually accomplishes this by transferring some amount of public assets over to the private corporation in the process, which is a net loss for everyone. It's a backhanded way of looting the public's funds under the veneer of "progress" and "cooperation".
Or for a simple analogy, public-private partnerships are usually the governmental version of a reverse mortgage.