News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steve Wozniak: Android will be the dominant smartphone pl... by spot on Thursday November 18, 2010 @07:59AM (#1917612)
otoh, iOS still doesn't have a decent notification system or multitasking. major capabilities like that might be more important than fragmentation, which effects both platforms and is only a problem for smaller devs. i have done some android work and "wicked" is an exaggeration. i am not aware of anyone who cares if there is a keyboard or not. it's completely abstracted by the OS.
Re:Steve Wozniak: Android will be the dominant smartphone pl... by fmw on Thursday November 18, 2010 @08:31AM (#1917674)
We've seen products lacking certain "major" features win from more technically advanced competitors before. Because regular consumers don't care about the same things that geeks do. Look at the iPod. Not to mention other reasons that give an edge to a product (e.g. the porn industry backing a certain media format that consequently beats its competition). In my opinion the most important feature is freedom, contrary to the locked platform you get with iOS. Android isn't perfect in that regard, but at least a step in the right direction. Sadly, most people don't care enough about freedom to let it determine their purchasing decisions (although they do like to complain after the fact when they can't port their data to another device).
Re:Steve Wozniak: Android will be the dominant smartphone pl... by loewenskind on Thursday November 18, 2010 @09:20AM (#1917800)
>Sadly, most people don't care enough about freedom

What most people don't care about is thoughtless spin like this. It's not "free" vs. "draconian lock down", it's a trade off. Android lets you do anything you want, in which case people... do anything they want. Apple puts controls in place on what can be done. That means you can get more things quicker on the Anroid but it also means you can apps that steal your credit card info, etc.

It's a trade off and both sides have advantages and disadvantages. Stop with this disingenuous "it's about freedom!" nonsense.

Re:Steve Wozniak: Android will be the dominant smartphone pl... by fmw on Thursday November 18, 2010 @12:26PM (#1918523)
Sure, it is a trade off and you misunderstand me if you think I'm attacking Apple because of some "be free or die" mentality. I'm not attacking anyone. I'm typing this on a Mac and actually own an iPhone, even if I use a HTC Desire instead. But that doesn't make caring about freedom "thoughtless spin". Using words like that doesn't do justice to a legitimate concern. Getting locked into a platform is a serious pain. I also don't agree with the idea that you can do pretty much whatever you want on Android as it comes pre-installed on your phone, which is how most regular people use their phones (just like the fact that they don't jailbreak their iPhones). That argument seems like the same black and white "free" vs. "draconian lock down" comparison that you disagree with.

Apple knows that mainstream consumers don't care about freedom, just like most citizens don't really care about limitations to their civil rights until it gets to the point where they are groped by the TSA on the airport (i.e. the "if you've got nothing to hide..." mentality). Living in a country like Singapore definitely has its benefits, just as closed computer platforms do. If you're not a power user your data usually doesn't matter that much, anyway, so losing it if you switch to another system doesn't seem like such a big deal when you're deciding about what product to buy. This is exactly the reason why people buy a new version of Microsoft Office every two years. To me, however, my data matters and I get frustrated when I can't synch my iPhone from my GNU/Linux box without jumping through all sorts of hoops. I might not be the typical user, but I still want free platforms to disrupt closed ones (note that disrupt doesn't mean that I don't want them to coexist; choice is good). Just like I want (old versions of) Internet Explorer to die in favor of more open alternatives.

Just to clarify: this is not a black and white position and I don't have anything against Apple, or even Microsoft (in fact, I think Microsoft is more open than Apple these days). My main point was that having more features doesn't make or break a product, but that being said the side-note about freedom was a serious concern that I deeply care about when it comes to investing time and data into a platform.

Re:Steve Wozniak: Android will be the dominant smartphone pl... by loewenskind on Friday November 19, 2010 @05:35AM (#1921034)
What I have an issue with is this assumption that Apple is trying to do evil platform lock in. A lot of what they're doing makes their devices much more convenient to use than they could be otherwise. Perhaps that's a happy coincidence, perhaps it isn't. How would you tell if they were doing it to be "evil" or not? It would look about the same.

Of course you could say that they could just make a way for power users to get by all this stuff and that's true, but based on Jobs behavior in the past he seems to be terrified of someone having his stuff crash and blame it on Apple even if it was totally the users fault [1]. They nearly died to Microsoft because of this very thing and history may repeat against Anroid.

[1] You might say that's really silly, but most of Windows reputation for being unstable came from 3rd party software.

Re:Steve Wozniak: Android will be the dominant smartphone pl... by Daishiman on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:19AM (#1918237)
It's disingenuous until the day Apple decides your phone has reached EOL without your consent, ro the da, you know, you want to use anything that's not iTunes to sync data.
Re:Steve Wozniak: Android will be the dominant smartphone pl... by loewenskind on Friday November 19, 2010 @05:28AM (#1921022)
I already use something that isn't iTunes to sync data. I'm using MobileMe but you can also use other cloud services for this.
Re:Steve Wozniak: Android will be the dominant smartphone pl... by DanHulton on Thursday November 18, 2010 @08:20AM (#1917659)
Yeah, I'd really enjoy some better multitasking/background stuff on the iPhone, I'm sure. Then again, I'm certain that there would be apps that would abuse it and drain the heck outta my battery.

Man, it would be nice if there was a system utility that showed how much of the battery each app drained, so you could keep track of the worst offenders. Even if just a good estimate, like % of processor time * amount drained while active.

Re:Steve Wozniak: Android will be the dominant smartphone pl... by dhoe on Thursday November 18, 2010 @08:29AM (#1917669)
Android has that.
Re:Steve Wozniak: Android will be the dominant smartphone pl... by DougWebb on Thursday November 18, 2010 @09:56AM (#1917920)
Yeah it does, but it's not as useful as you'd think. On my phone, the breakdown is always like 40% Display, 30% Idle, 20% for various system things, and the last 10% is stuff I can actually control. My display is set to auto brightness, but it has a short shutoff timer and I shut it off manually most of the time when I stop looking at it. I've tried low brightness settings but that didn't make much difference. Wireless, Bluetooth, and GPS don't make much difference either but I always keep them off.

The one thing that seems to make a huge difference is having the cell signal on when there is no tower in range. The phone gets hot and burns battery juice when it's trying to find a tower. My office has lousy reception, so on days when the signal is bad my battery is nearly dead by the time I'm ready to go home.

It used to be completely dead almost every day unless I recharged during the day, but I bought an extended battery. They should just come with the bigger batteries, even if the phones cost a bit more. It only sticks out a bit, and makes the battery life much more livable.

Re:Steve Wozniak: Android will be the dominant smartphone pl... by sigzero on Thursday November 18, 2010 @09:13AM (#1917785)
Joe Public doesn't care about that. Not really.
Re:Steve Wozniak: Android will be the dominant smartphone pl... by Kliment on Thursday November 18, 2010 @09:57AM (#1917926)
No. But developers do. That way they can make sure their app is not a battery drain without having to wait for hours. And once this is a priority to developers, Joe Public benefits.
Re:Steve Wozniak: Android will be the dominant smartphone pl... by redrobot5050 on Thursday November 18, 2010 @09:28PM (#1920180)
iOS developers have more powerful tools than a task tracker app available to them in the SDK.
Re:Steve Wozniak: Android will be the dominant smartphone pl... by jokermatt999 on Thursday November 18, 2010 @10:49AM (#1918110)
No, but Joe Public's technical friend can use it to show him what's eating his battery. Just because a non-technical person doesn't use a feature doesn't mean it's useless.