Re:Don’t Get Clever with Login Forms
by underwater on Friday February 15, 2019 @09:17PM
(#19176586)
Users who use their own password manager are also amongst the most technical. Optimising login UI so they can login a little quicker, at the cost of confusing the average user, is a terrible trade off.
For example Office365 uses a single email input on the login form. For enterprise users clicking "next" triggers an SSO flow that skips any password prompt.
If Office365 adopted the suggestions from the article and added a password field Brad Frost would be able to log in to his personal account from a single button press - a small optimisation for him - but many more users would be confused about the presence of a password input and potentially even be stopped from using the product at all.
I'm not so sure you're right in the general case, modern password managers are aimed at fairly normal people, there may very well be millions of password manager users.
Nevertheless, even if we're a "rounding error" we are often decision makers. So deliberately not supporting our workflow may make it surprisingly hard to get us on board, or to keep us from recommending one of your competitors just because it annoyed us to use your workflow instead of ours.
Several people below have suggested tricks that preserve your desired behaviour (people don't go down rabbit holes for other auth methods that weren't for them anyway) while making password managers still work. Those are better than what you do now, so, do that.