News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Time Travel (2006) by coldtea on Friday February 15, 2019 @09:34AM (#19171186)
>But this sentence makes it all nonsense - as there's no proof for time existing.

First, if we're realists/utilitarian/pragmatists we don't need some fancy proof for time existing. We can see that the material world changes and we call that time. We even measure that passage with clocks. We even know (and have proven experimentally) that things going faster slow down clocks on them. So, whether time "really exists" or not is a meaningless question when we're concerned with time as we experience and know it.

It's like someone shooting a bullet at you, and you are asking "yes, but does this bullet _really_ exist?". Well, it might not (e.g. we might all live in a simulation, or the nature of physical objects might be just some probability distribution of information, and not "exist" in the plain sense we understand it), but in this life as we know it, a bullet hitting you will still have the consequences we know and expect.

Second, time exists in Relativity equations, so there's that.

>Time is a useful abstraction for calculating physical models, making forecasts. As we have other useful abstractions in math or programming - it doesn't make them existing in real world.

Doesn't matter. It's enough that we can measure it, we don't care for the "thing in itself" or if it's merely some illusion. We live in a universe where whether it's an illusion or not, it has the same effects for us (e.g. we grow old, things change state, our clock dials rotate).

Re:Time Travel (2006) by madmaniak on Friday February 15, 2019 @10:19AM (#19171550)
I'm glad you've bothered to answer.

I don't need a fancy proof either - any proof would be enough. What we both can agree is that things or processes are happening. They don't need time for that. Constant change, constant mutation doesn't require past or future, but now only. But as I said, we - intelligent species - need a concept of time to predict how the change will proceed.

What we measure in clocks depends on a clock - a sand falling down in a sand glass, a pendulum or a spring cycle and so on. After this we make a relation from this event and start to measure other events with it. Still it's just things happening, not a prove of a time existence.

If you say that you experience time. Well. That's how neural network works - they are shaped by events/impulses which happened to the network and accessing this information gives you illusion of a past - but this information encoded in your brain exists now.

> Doesn't matter. It's enough that we can measure it, we don't care for the "thing in itself" or if it's merely some illusion. We live in a universe where whether it's an illusion or not, it has the same effects for us (e.g. we grow old, things change state, our clock dials rotate).

So we agree in a part that things change state and this is enough to imply growing old and rotating clocks. I don't agree it doesn't matter - as if the time doesn't exist, we don't need to have a pointless discussion about "travelling in time".

Re:Time Travel (2006) by coldtea on Friday February 15, 2019 @10:47AM (#19171806)
>Constant change, constant mutation doesn't require past or future, but now only.

The change itself might not, but to perceive something as having changed, e.g. to understand that what is in N state now was in some N - 1 state before, and N - 2 before that, presupposes time (or rather, can be considered the same thing as time).

>So we agree in a part that things change state and this is enough to imply growing old and rotating clocks. I don't agree it doesn't matter - as if the time doesn't exist, we don't need to have a pointless discussion about "travelling in time".

It wouldn't be pointless as to the actual phenomena we'd experience. It would the same as asking "since we see we can grow old, or see the clock hand rotating, can we somehow manage to go to the now moment when we were young, or where the clock hand was 1 hour before?".

Re:Time Travel (2006) by madmaniak on Friday February 15, 2019 @12:16PM (#19172674)
So the question is, when you broke a vase can you glue it back to the previous state - and the answer is yes. The more exact state you'd like to achieve the more effort it will require. But having the same state again doesn't mean you've travelled in time, but only that somehow the same state occur one more time (or better to say once again ;) ).
Re:Time Travel (2006) by kelnos on Friday February 15, 2019 @06:25PM (#19175728)
I think what the parent is getting at is that the progression of states is time. If you think of time as just the entire universe morphing through a progression of different quantum states, and then find a way to modify the quantum state of the entire universe so that it is equivalent to a previous quantum state, then "traveling through time" would easily be a colloquial way of saying what you've done.

Though I suppose you didn't really travel; you reset everything -- including yourself -- to a previous state/time. If you could isolate yourself, and then return the rest of the universe to some previous state (while finding a coherent place for your personal newer state in the old rest-of-universe state, possibly editing out the parts of the universe's state that contain the old you), then "traveling" would make more sense.

> but only that somehow the same state occur one more time

Assuming that state transitions are deterministic (apart from your meddling that allowed you to return to a prior state, that is), then this is equivalent to rolling back time, so the distinction doesn't really matter. If you pick a quantum state that occurred 10 years ago (by your subjective perception of time), then everyone will be 10 years younger, people who were born in the last 10 years will no longer exist, and people who died in the last 10 years will be alive again.

Also remember that everyone has their own reference frame when determining time. There's no such thing as "absolute time", or even the absolute passage of time. But that's ok; we don't need that to be the case for this to work out.

Re:Time Travel (2006) by coldtea on Friday February 15, 2019 @06:32PM (#19175779)
That's for a vase. Why would it have to be the same for time? This presupposes that time is unidirectional -- which it was supposed to prove.
Re:Time Travel (2006) by CuriousSkeptic on Friday February 15, 2019 @01:30PM (#19173413)
When you go back to this moment. Would you then expect to have the experience of remembering “the future”? Would it still be “the moment we were young” or something different? If the moment is different in this way, can it still count as the past? If it isn’t, what makes you think you’ve only experienced it once?
Re:Time Travel (2006) by coldtea on Friday February 15, 2019 @06:31PM (#19175771)
>When you go back to this moment. Would you then expect to have the experience of remembering “the future”?

Yes.

>If the moment is different in this way, can it still count as the past?

Well, several answers here.

a) If it's the same in every other way, then it's good enough as "the past" to me.

b) We understand things as substantially the same all the time even though they've changed in small or big ways (e.g. we consider ourselves the same person as the child we once were, we consider a city to still be the same city even though new buildings have come up/gone down as time passes, etc.). So why not consider the past + that difference as "the past"?

c) What else could it be? It's surely not the future, and it looks a hella lot like the past. At worst, we could say it's a new divergent version of our original past.

(But how would we even know it's a divergent version? Nothing might have changed, our trip might be a closed loop, where we always were to visit the past -- that is, there was never a past at time X without us visiting it from the future).

Re:Time Travel (2006) by justinpombrio on Friday February 15, 2019 @11:22AM (#19172102)
At some point you're going to realize that this kind of argument applies to everything else as well, not just time. When that happens, I do hope you'll give us back the word "exists". It's a useful word.
Re:Time Travel (2006) by reallydude on Friday February 15, 2019 @04:55PM (#19175075)
As I understand it,

You're traveling at the speed of light. You have your perception of entropical change and an observer has theirs. There is no singular time that "exists". There are multiple perceptions that "exist". Time itself is not existing, as much as it is a perception of process(es). Humans mark states and compare later. This is not time, this is a measure of states. The term time is a shorthand for that, to the detriment of comprehending/understanding what it (the term Time) is describing.

Re:Time Travel (2006) by madmaniak on Friday February 15, 2019 @12:45PM (#19172952)
Word exists is useful, the same like the concept of time. I don't take it anywhere no worries.

"This kind of argument" you mean "argument"? Arguments applies to everything, agree. This kind of argument applies first of all to time and possibly to something else by analogy. Beauty of reasoning.

But if in some hypothetical universe, you realise by arguments, that nothing exists - what's the reason of "giving back the word" which in this hypothetical universe has no meaning? I don't follow this logic.

Re:Time Travel (2006) by justinpombrio on Friday February 15, 2019 @01:49PM (#19173576)
> This kind of argument applies first of all to time and possibly to something else by analogy.

I think you'll find that your argument that time does not exist also applies to literally everything else. Space does not exist. Matter does not exist. People do not exist. There is no clearly defined moment of birth or death, or boundary between a person and the rest of the world; thus "people" don't exist. To use your words:

If you say that you experience seeing distinct people. Well. That's how neural networks work - they categorize the events/impulses which happened to the network into distinct objects that didn't exist in the events/impulses themselves.

> But if in some hypothetical universe, you realise by arguments, that nothing exists - what's the reason of "giving back the word" which in this hypothetical universe has no meaning? I don't follow this logic.

If you define a word such that it never applies, you're communicating badly. By the above arguments, nothing exists. And by the definition of the word "exists" that you're using, that's correct: nothing exists.

But that's a dumb way to define "exists". It's a perfectly useful word. And you should give it a more reasonable definition such that time, space, and people exist.

Re:Time Travel (2006) by madmaniak on Friday February 15, 2019 @03:22PM (#19174365)
I don't get your arguments about not existing people, matter, and space. I try hard though.
Re:Time Travel (2006) by coldtea on Friday February 15, 2019 @06:41PM (#19175837)
Perhaps not hard enough.

What the parent says is take your argument for time not existing:

"If you say that you experience time. Well. That's how neural network works - they are shaped by events/impulses which happened to the network and accessing this information gives you illusion of a past - but this information encoded in your brain exists now."

By the same logic, matter doesn't exist either.

Our brains [1] perceive a material world, but it's only a as thoughts an impressions they do so. There doesn't need (nor do we have of there existing) an actual material world. A neural network as complex as our brain that gets the same weights and is fed the same events/impulses as raw information (e.g. digits of input) would see the same "material" world.

No more reason for the material world to exist, than there's for time.

In fact, perhaps it's just my own brain, alone, as perhaps I'm the only actual person in the universe. What proof do I have that anybody else is not a "non playing character"?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solipsism)

Re:Time Travel (2006) by madmaniak on Saturday February 16, 2019 @03:55AM (#19177809)
No. I'm saying about technical aspect of neural networks which are shaped by experienced signals - which in other words is encoding information about what we call past. That's why we can tell what happen before - because we have encoded information about it in our brain - but before doesn't exist any more as it mutated to different state and there is nowhere to travel. You can bring back previous state, but it's not travelling in time in a way like Hollywood shows. I'm not going any further here into claiming that everything is an illusion. Not because of limitations of your brain you will not pass through walls. There's not the same logic here as you're saying.

About Solipsism - for sure in the universe you're living in you're the only one, as your perception is unique. We all have our own universes of thoughts. There's no proof for the question, that's why you should accept such possibility.

Re:Time Travel (2006) by GoblinSlayer on Friday February 15, 2019 @11:25AM (#19172127)
If there's only now - that's zero dimensional time, but it's still existing time, it's just not an extended dimension.
Re:Time Travel (2006) by madmaniak on Friday February 15, 2019 @12:13PM (#19172636)
Which also implies there's nowhere to travel in this case.
Re:Time Travel (2006) by coldtea on Friday February 15, 2019 @06:46PM (#19175861)
Not really.

A reconfiguration of the matter on the world on the same state would still be exactly equivalent to a travel back in time (to that "now") in that case.

And such a time travel might not even take active agency to happen:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poincar%C3%A9_recurrence_theor...

Re:Time Travel (2006) by madmaniak on Saturday February 16, 2019 @04:03AM (#19177829)
It would be an equivalent but not travelling in time itself. If I will go by car to point B I can't say I was travelling by train just because of the same result.

Occurring the same state is obvious on condition of finite amount of state and infinite amount of mutations. The question is if amount of states are finite.