The effectiveness of enforcement is no argument.
Inability to enforce is exactly why prohibition has been a colossal failure, so how is the ability to enforce irrelevant to a law's success?
We collectively agree to ban certain things (e.g. murder), because there are multiple reasons to do so. Some of these reasons are humanitarian, some rational, some economic etc. Yet we see proof each day that neither laws nor punishment will stop murder from happening.
The idea of a ban is not to stop things — but to increase the (social, economical, ...) cost of certain behaviour.
Any actor who fears that cost will abstain from chemical weapons for example. But just like with murder you will always have actors that either decide it is a prize worth taking, or they never ever thought about it at all.
Hard to say how effective those bans were, but they certainly helped to nudge some actors into adopting higher standards.
And once there is a standard the majority agrees on it is hard to go back to a lower standard..
Politicaly costly, as more and more people pressured for more human ways of war. Because mines are a very effective and cheap military strategy. (where mines are you don't need so much troops). I say it was the boulevard pictures of children without legs, that did it. And maybe will so again after the first killbots gone rouge..
Because I doubt any big military would miss out the opportunity to at least be able to flip the switch to let them operate and shoot autonom, when you have more cheap massproduced robots than operators and need them and or the enemy is jamming you and the situation is critical.
Land mines are by far the cheapest modern method for area denial unless we're considering dirty bombs.
We’re hoping society agrees that making autonomous lethal robots should be Bad and deserve punitive consequences. And hopefully, those who commit this crime will be caught and suffer the consequences.
Laws should be clear and non-burdensome for the majority. And violations caught at the high rate. My 2c.
The first case they may bury bodies and set an armed patrol of some sort for roving bandits but the murderer would never be punished per say.
However if nearly everyone drinks and alcohol is illegal but bars operate openly yeah that law is bad it is only being used as a pretext.
No human agreement will ever be able to stop a 100% of anything. But that doesn’t imply it isn’t worth increasing the cost (financial, social and otherwise) to certain types of behaviour.
People seem to agree quite uniformly with banning and punishing murder for example, although these laws and punishments don’t seem to stop murder as has been proven over centuries. Few would murder their neighbour over a small dispute, because the cost for doing so is extremely high. Much more people would e.g. kill the rapist of their child, because the notion of cost might be irrelevant under such circumstances and it is much more socially acceptable to do so.
Of course there is more than just cost. It can also be a matter of culture. If you live in a culture were getting shot for miniscule reasons is not something that happens, you are also far less likely to see shooting at somebody for miniscule reasons as an option
Just like the world can mostly agree it was evil to arrange a civil war in Eastern Ukraine or invade Iraq etc etc:
There will always be people who more or less genuinely argue that the last invasion of Iraq was necessary or that a certain superpower next to Ukraine has nothing to do with the well supplied rebels in their back yard.
For the rest of us we can all agree to despise both of these.
I think hacker news should be above inflammatory posts like these.
I posted something I was sure most HN-ers could agree on, - but as someone who frequently disagrees with many of you I probably should have known better.
Some people are scared of that and don't do the forbidden thing.
Take the act of stealing for example. It is ridiculously easy to do and indeed it is committed a lot. Yet most societies prefer to ban it, hoping that fear of sentence will prevent some people to do it.