News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon in Its Prime: Doubles Profits, Pays $0 in Federal ... by dragonwriter on Thursday February 14, 2019 @09:02AM (#19161892)
> France has a similar presidential system. It's a purely cultural thing.

But France doesn't use simple one-round FPTP for either the Presidential or legislative elections, and doesn't combine the elections, either, using a two-rond majority-runoff system for each election (with additionally what amounts to a minimum threshold by eligible electorate size, rather than just share of turnout, for legislative seats for first-round wins.) Majority-runoff has a far less strong push to duopoly thaneither simple FPTP or the US Presidential election system.

It's not purely a cultural thing; to the extent it's cultural, it's largely cultural adaptation to structural incentives.

> You could argue the duopoly prevents extremism by straightjacking the political options, but after the Tea Party takeover the GOP and now Trump, that has been thoroughly debunked.

I wouldn't have argued that in the first place for other reasons, but Trump would, at worst, only debunk an absurdly absolutist version of that; electoral systems may structurally disfavor certain outcomes but they rarely absolutely prevent any particular ideological outcome.

There are no comments on this comment yet.