Re:Scientists Are Rethinking Animal Cognition
by get_off_my_lawn on Thursday February 14, 2019 @10:09AM
(#19162370)
Fair enough, let's assume that in the previous analogy I am actually the parent footing the hospital bill. If I know for certain that you are going to recover, and I can afford it, but decide to let you die anyway, is that really significantly better?
However, I do acknowledge that there are exceptional circumstances, such as the birth posing a health risk to the mother, both mother and child being likely to die if delivery is attempted, etc. That would be the case of "not being able to afford it" in my analogy, or the significant personal risk you mention (at least I assume that's what you mean, as normal pregnancy is nowhere near a significant risk, with the current maternal death rate being 1 in 10,000). In those cases, I'd be willing to agree with you.
in the specific case of pregnancy, the support is given at significant personal cost and risk, which is not captured in either of your analogies.