News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open ID Is A Nightmare by tptacek on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @03:57PM (#1915707)
If you get to stipulate browser support, you can do much more interesting things than OpenID. Not requiring browser support to be viable is part of the point of OpenID and OAuth.
Re:Open ID Is A Nightmare by mcantor on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @04:03PM (#1915736)
I think that's what the OP is lamenting: That we've traded one problem (remembering which screen name/e-mail address and password you used to log in) with another one (remembering which OpenID you used to sign up, and dealing with the technical repercussions therein), while there is a seemingly superior solution out there (let the browser(s) handle it).
Re:Open ID Is A Nightmare by Hkaccc on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:00AM (#1918157)
On the other hand, authenticating users by their browser is like authenticating passengers by the car they're in.
Re:Open ID Is A Nightmare by Groxx on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @07:27PM (#1916311)
Where am I "stipulating" browser support? I'm saying it could be easier with browser support. Easy enough to the point where people would prefer it, causing everything to support it instead of the anemic few we have now.

This is one of those areas where people improving security frequently seem to fail to comprehend human behavior. For OpenID to gain critical mass, the average person has to be able to use it simply and correctly enough that they will make the switch. And that implies incredible simplicity. OpenID has the capability, but it seems implementers go out of their way to make the process anything but simple, so people get confused and leave for a lock-in solution like Facebook that has a single button to press.

You get people to improve their habits by being easier than their old habits, not by telling them their old habits are dangerous and look, here's a better option. If that worked, people wouldn't be drinking and smoking so much.