Re:Silicon Valley Is Using Trade Secrets to Hide Its Race Pr...
by darkpuma on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @01:50PM
(#19155563)
Given the link between tech work and depression, and more generally the link between depression and careers with very little physical activity, I think it's unconscionable to modify the preferences of people who would otherwise prefer to not work in tech.
By all means, help people who desire it. By why 'correct' people who don't?
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using Trade Secrets to Hide Its Race Pr...
by darawk on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @03:23PM
(#19156582)
Ya, i'm not a huge fan of 'correcting' people's preferences. I do think it's possible that part of the issue is how women are socialized, and it's also possible part of the issue is how CS is taught. However, I think the lion's share of the variance is explained by biologically innate preferences, and while there could be good arguments for changing those, I don't see any being made at the moment.
To be clear, i'm including 'preference' as a sub-component of 'pipeline problem'. I think it's a cultural open question whether or not we consider this a 'problem'. I think the argument for preference is much stronger on the gender question though, than on the minority question. There's strong psych research indicating preferences against programming for women, but i'm not aware of any for say, African Americans. In the minority case, I suspect it's more of an access/opportunity issue early on, but i'm open to many views of these issues.