Re:Do the non-religious have greater brand loyalty?
by anthuswilliams on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @06:23PM
(#1916159)
His point is not contradicted by the data. He's questioning the paper's claim that people self-identify using corporate brands, saying instead that nonreligious people stick with brands that have worked for them in the past whereas religious people believe whatever the label tells them.
Obviously, he's not expressing that claim as true. He's using it to point out that, given imagination and a sufficiently broad brush, this set of data can be interpreted to cast aspersions on any group you wish.
Re:Do the non-religious have greater brand loyalty?
by weaksauce on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @04:15PM
(#1915778)
So there was a question on there talking about self worth and brand loyalty? If not I think that's a large brush to paint with.
Re:Do the non-religious have greater brand loyalty?
by jerf on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @05:07PM
(#1915951)
Why are you asking me what the page says, when you can read it for yourself?
Re:Do the non-religious have greater brand loyalty?
by weaksauce on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @09:04PM
(#1916554)
I actually wasn't talking about the page. I was talking about the content of the study. I dislike the summary view of research papers because they tend to skew things the way they want it to be skewed. When I have actual data(hopefully not fabricated but you hope better from scientists.) I can look at the test methodology and decide if it is valid data. The way it seems to me is that the test was done in a misleading way but that is only because there is no data that I can see.
With the conviction you had from reading it I assumed that you had access to the actual report and not a biased summary.
Uh, no, this whole thing is based on data collected in a study. Question the interpretation of the data or the provenance of the data based on the paper if you like, but this isn't just some sort of wild speculation, this is an explanation of the pattern contained in the data. Your "hypothesis" is not merely "an alternative possibility", it is "a thing contradicted by the data as collected", a rather different thing.