News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK Government: will not support Net Neutrality by alextgordon on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @10:02AM (#1914416)
To give a real world example:

Quite a few ISPs in the UK institute bandwidth caps. Sometimes these caps can be horrendously expensive compared to the real cost of the bandwidth (i.e. high markup).

But there's also quite a few ISPs with no unreasonable bandwidth caps. I have the choice to use one of these ISPs instead (and I do).

Same deal with net neutrality. If non-neutral ISPs pop up, then you can be sure that neutral ones will too. There's no better selling point than "we're cheaper than those guys".

I think the government is right not to mess with a well functioning market when there's not even a problem yet. I'm not so keen on them trying to spin non-neutral practices into a good thing (this may just be the article sensationalising).

Re:UK Government: will not support Net Neutrality by bruceboughton on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @10:37AM (#1914530)
As a counter example, if can only get your broadband via cable, you're stuck with Virgin Media (I think) who have quite an onerous capping policy [1] unless you fork out for 50Mb fibre optic.

[1] http://shop.virginmedia.com/help/traffic-management/traffic-... - in particular, note the evening fair use amount: 3.5Gb

Re:UK Government: will not support Net Neutrality by shrikant on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @11:21AM (#1914700)
Sadly, you can't choose to get your broadband "only via cable" - Virgin still requires you to pony up for the phone line.

I'm currently paying Sky £10 a month for a landline phone that I will never use, and £11 a month for the Internet.

Re:UK Government: will not support Net Neutrality by g_lined on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @12:11PM (#1914860)
Virgin offer packages which don't require a BT Line. It may be that you are not cabled up suitably for such a deal (we used to pay our cable operator, now Virgin, for a telephone line which we could not get but they gave us 'free' TV which is what we actually wanted to buy).

http://shop.virginmedia.com//bundles/specials/affiliate/dual...

All other providers do require a BT line, though some people would say it's a landline phone line that you /always/ use...assuming you leave your router on.

Re:UK Government: will not support Net Neutrality by axod on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @01:19PM (#1915101)
> "All other providers do require a BT line"

Untrue. Most exchanges now have LLU which allows you to get your phone+ADSL from other providers. You may still need to get your phone line from BT, but that's not the case in many places.

Re:UK Government: will not support Net Neutrality by axod on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @01:00PM (#1915031)
The vast majority can get ADSL now. I believe coverage is 95%+

Obviously it sucks for the few exchanges that can't do ADSL. Then your only real options are 3G, satellite, or install your own dedicated line.

Re:UK Government: will not support Net Neutrality by axod on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @10:12AM (#1914452)
Good example.

As for the spin, I think it's good to give people choice. For example if people want to get a cheaper internet connection that's watered down version without 'premium' websites which cost extra, then that's fair enough.

I don't think anything like that would work well though. People expect the internet to mean 'everything' on a level playing field.