News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thank PG: For reclaiming the word 'hacker' by raganwald on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @09:51AM (#1914369)
Compare to Sales. There are slimy people who sell products that don't work. There are great salespeople who transform businesses and people's lives for the better.

I'm sure lots of salespeople cringe at the thought of being associated with the slimeballs. But yet... It's all Sales and they are all salespeople.

EDIT: By all means call yourself "constructive." But it is not a requirement of hacking. How was stealing telecommunications services constructive for the telecommunications companies?

Re:Thank PG: For reclaiming the word 'hacker' by user24 on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @10:03AM (#1914425)
This is worrying then. That's a good argument, that phreaking wasn't constructive. I once started making a Lego robot that could play my gameboy. That's not constructive at all either.

But I'd like both of those to be great examples of hacking.

Is the important distinction motivation then? That phreaks weren't motivated by an urge to crash the system but by an undying curiosity about how things work?

Re:Thank PG: For reclaiming the word 'hacker' by raganwald on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @10:20AM (#1914482)
In the 1970s there were these hackers and they did certain things we admire today. I only fear that we will put them on a pedestal and say that that was hacking but what kids do today is not hacking.

That's a little like saying that Jazz died with Miles Davis and that we should call it "African-American Classical Music" and when kids do something offensive today like slapping a saxophone reed or a tuba mouthpiece with their tongues (James Carter and John Sass, respectively), it's not Jazz, it's noise.

I just don't trust myself to know how to say that subverting the telephone system by emulating tones is hacking but routing 15% of the world's IP traffic through your computers for military purposes is not hacking. I can only say that I admire the first and deplore the second.

p.s. And yeah, Go Go Lego! I suggest there's an "air" of subversion involved with hacking, but just a whiff. If it makes you happy, Hack On!

Re:Thank PG: For reclaiming the word 'hacker' by user24 on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @09:54AM (#1914388)
maybe they need to reclaim the word Salesperson from the slimeballs then ;)
Re:Thank PG: For reclaiming the word 'hacker' by raganwald on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @10:01AM (#1914413)
Yes please!

I suggest that the net harm to society from slimeball salespeople outweighs the net harm to society from black hat hackers by so many orders of magnitude that a comparison involves astronomical entities like red giants being compared to planetoids.

I would ask you to think about the computer business if we could remove the enterprise salespeople, but my mouth is watering so much that I can't finish typing my comment...

Re:Thank PG: For reclaiming the word 'hacker' by fractallyte on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @10:21AM (#1914483)
I wonder if 'lawyer' will ever be (re)claimed...