"Your ISP doesn't support the BBC IPlayer - please let them know about it here"
strikes me as a pretty obvious marketing tool.
In exactly the same way, not providing access to youtube would probably be the most moronic thing most ISPs could do.
If the BBC pay anybody else beyond their own bandwidth costs, the top brass should be sacked.
What we have here is fundamentally ISPs trying to run a private toll booth by claiming that 'others are profiting from their network'. Not at all true. The BBC, YouTube, whoever, all pay their outgoing bandwidth bills to their network provided. I pay my incoming bandwidth bill to my network provider (and outgoing, for that matter, when I put my content provider hat on and legally upload to various sites). All parties are getting correctly paid in proportion to the value of the services that they are delivering, but the ISPs know they are a critical man-in-the-middle and can potentially extract value from this proposition in exactly the same way that rebel armies set up 'checkpoints' in territories they control.
ISPs should be ashamed that they're trying it. The Conservative Party should be utterly ashamed that they think it's a good idea and I plan to write to my local (Conservative) MP to inform him of this.
The sheer quality of programming they put out. Buy a license.
[EDITED to add: But if you watch a programme at the same time as it's being broadcast, you do need a licence.]
Then you don't know much about the BBC, it's been farming work out to private companies for a lloooonng time. Do you think it currently gets its bandwidth for free? Or provided by another government department?
(Disclaimer: these views are my own, etc.)
I really hope that if they go ahead with this that they clear all barriers to allow the BBC to run it's own ISP, and compete on selection of netural traffic. At least that way, people get a choice how many times they pay for the same content.
What good is video content streaming from a public broadcaster if you have to pay private organisations again to see that content you've already paid the BBC for?