Re:Generating code from natural language is closer than you ...
by alanh on Tuesday November 16, 2010 @10:11PM
(#1912732)
I upvoted you. But I am not sure that "/thing/other thing/" is more concise or useful than all alternatives.
"thing" → "other thing" is the same length, and while not natural language, it isn’t a computer language.
I think using the sed-like (right?) language is more useful as a signaller. Check it out, yo, I grep shit all the time.
Re:Generating code from natural language is closer than you ...
by silentbicycle on Tuesday November 16, 2010 @11:33PM
(#1912920)
The whole s/X/Y/ thing is very Unix, and is a (sub)cultural signifier as much as anything. I'm not sure if it's originally from ed, sed, or what, but most people (self included) probably picked it up from vi (nvi/vim/etc.) or perl.
X->Y makes just as much sense, but the s (for "substitute") makes it mnemonic - I read it as "sub X for Y".
Re:Generating code from natural language is closer than you ...
by aaronblohowiak on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @12:18AM
(#1913019)
ed gave rise to sed and vi. ed -> em -> ex (VIsual mode). vim is Vi iMproved.
x->y suggests lambda to many people in our community.
Edit: I meant to provide some additional information to other readers, not to disagree in any way.
Re:Generating code from natural language is closer than you ...
by silentbicycle on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @12:21AM
(#1913024)
Well, right, but how many people here have actually used ed standalone? (lone hand) It's overwhelmingly likely that most people picked it up from vi(m).
Re:Generating code from natural language is closer than you ...
by ctkrohn on Tuesday November 16, 2010 @10:17PM
(#1912743)
This is comes up in Charles Stross's novel "Accelerando." He imagines a relatively near future where children grow up speaking partially synthetic languages. It's one of my favorite novels; you can read it online, too: http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/fiction/accelera...
Stross is also an occasional commenter here on HN.
You already see this in places like hacker news here where people often use constructs like "s/thing/other thing/" because it's more concise and useful than writing out the natural language version.