Re:The exercise “recovery” industry is largely bogus
by kerkeslager on Saturday February 09, 2019 @11:45AM
(#19123216)
Right, but I don't think that's really indicative of the "exercise recovery" industry. Bottled water, of course, is an industry, but I don't know of a company that's specifically trying to sell water for exercise recovery. It's just water, it's fairly well known that humans need that, especially when exercising.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The exercise “recovery” industry is largely bogus
by ip26 on Saturday February 09, 2019 @12:10PM
(#19123377)
I guess it's this part I'm reacting to more than anything:
“We’re taught we can’t trust our bodies and that it’s not enough to listen to your thirst.” But it turns out thirst is a great indicator of dehydration.
“You really can use [thirst] to know whether it’s time to drink or not,” she said.
You'll get thirsty before you are dead. But for me I hit the wall before I really feel thirsty. Nobody describes feeling insatiably hungry and following their hunger as a strategy to avoid bonking- they manage their exertion and monitor their carb intake. For me & water, it is the same.
Perhaps there is some nuance here- perhaps, like with food, your body suppresses the drive to drink during endurance sports. But maybe when you sit on the bench after a play, you do reliably feel thirsty when you need it.
Re:The exercise “recovery” industry is largely bogus
by maxerickson on Saturday February 09, 2019 @10:36PM
(#19126241)
There's a product in the US that was initially marketed as "Propel Fitness Water".