Re:Spotify will now suspend or terminate accounts it finds a...
by userbinator on Friday February 08, 2019 @07:51PM
(#19119972)
It's irrelevant, because the publisher can deploy DRM in such a way as to make ad-blocking attempts illegal and easy to trace
How can they detect me covering the screen, looking away, or just not listening? How can that be illegal?
It's a cat-and-mouse game, and the mice will always win. Ultimately you'll get to the "analog hole of adblocking" situation anyway (user simply takes the headphones off or closes eyes or looks away etc.)
Re:Spotify will now suspend or terminate accounts it finds a...
by bad_user on Saturday February 09, 2019 @04:51AM
(#19121576)
> It's a cat-and-mouse game, and the mice will always win
You don't have much experience with actual cats hunting mice to make that analogy.
Mice can win by breeding, but a lot of mice die in the process while the cat is getting fat.
> ...how long until someone creates a solution to scrub the audio of ads in real-time?
Let me tell you a little open secret. Ad-blocking in general can be circumvented right now. Even the most aggressive ad-blocking techniques can be brought to their knees, because they can be detected and the website can serve the content in such a way as to make ads impossible to block without ruining the content.
Not many publishers do it because publishers have chosen to not piss off the minority that has ad-blockers installed. But this minority has been growing and what you're seeing is them fighting back.
You ask how long will it take to block audio ads? It's irrelevant, because the publisher can deploy DRM in such a way as to make ad-blocking attempts illegal and easy to trace, since the streaming is done in real time from a central source. And thus users can receive big fines as to stop everyone else from doing it.
That publishers don't do this yet, that's only because they preferred to play nice with ad-blockers. But threaten their bottom line long enough and they'll fight back.
And who can blame them? Here's Spotify with a pretty good subscription model and users are now up in arms for no longer being able to get their content for free without ads.