Re:ZFS and GPL terror: How much freedom is there in Linux?
by mustache_kimono on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @12:07PM
(#19154559)
It is worth noting that the GPL2-CDDL license incompatibility is still a theoretical legal issue, and that there are differing learned opinions with respect to the confluence of the CDDL, GPL2, and ZFS. For instance, Eben Moglen, co-author of the GPL3, has indicated that incompatibility is not an issue[0]. Many Sun employees have also disagreed that Sun's intent was to make the CDDL incompatible with the GPL2.
[0] https://www.softwarefreedom.org/resources/2016/linux-kernel-...
Re:ZFS and GPL terror: How much freedom is there in Linux?
by apple4ever on Sunday February 10, 2019 @08:42PM
(#19131453)
Being tired is not a good reason.
They need to stop being so stubborn.
>
>This is a claim supported primarily by one former employee of Sun. Others disagree. And even if it was verifiably true: What about Open Source values? Since when is the GPL the only acceptable Open Source license?
Lots of hand-waving and false equivalency here. We're not talking about "Open Source values", we're talking specifically about the Linux kernel. And the Linux kernel is GPLv2 licensed. The Software Freedom Conservancy analyzed the situation and determined that a GPL-licensed project cannot legally incorporate CDDL code into the binary[0].
FWIW, Ubuntu has done so anyway via a kernel module and yet has to be sued for it, but the Linux kernel project may still refrain from doing so out of an abundance of caution.
I believe someone else summed it up quite well when they said (paraphrasing), "Solaris intentionally made ZFS difficult to incorporate into Linux by the licensing, so the Linux developers are (understandably) tired of bending over backwards to try to accommodate ZFS."
[0]https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2016/feb/25/zfs-and-linux/