News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zappos offers new employees $3000 to quit after a week by bryanlarsen on Tuesday November 16, 2010 @03:32PM (#1911518)
Turning down $3000 requires people to internalize a solid commitment to the company. And engenders a huge sense of camaraderie when you know that everybody else you work with has also turned down the money.

And they get these two massive effects by NOT giving away money. It's worth the $3000 to get rid of employees who aren't that committed, but that's minor compared to the effects on the employees who stay.

Re:Zappos offers new employees $3000 to quit after a week by markng on Tuesday November 16, 2010 @07:21PM (#1912345)
I wonder how well this would work were it extended further into employment, too. A $3000 bonus to quit when you've worked somewhere for x years and are still in a job because of habit or fear could be a nice way to get rid of dead weight.
Re:Zappos offers new employees $3000 to quit after a week by phjohnst on Tuesday November 16, 2010 @08:14PM (#1912504)
I've always seen this policy as a way to lubricate the quitting process, rather than implicitly instil commitment from those that don't take it (like they're giving up something, so they must like what they're doing).

By paying people that arent committed to leave, you increase the proportion of good, loyal employees. Fewer half-assed people stick around.

Looking from an economic search cost perspective, if $3k > cost of searching for new job with payoff (both implicit and explicit) = working for Zappos, then you take the money and leave. Thus, the only people that stay are those that have higher search costs (and given a constant pay rate and 'hire-ability'[1], the only those with a higher implicit payoff, ie enjoyment) stay .

This only works as long as the pay to quit is less than the search cost for the threshold level of employee that you're trying to keep. It's also reliant on holding the 'hire-ability' of accepted applicants constant. But it means they can pretty much dictate the minimum level of 'enjoyment' that employees get from their jobs by adjusting the pay-to-quit figure.

Pretty cool.

With unemployment so high, search costs go up, which mean that they're probably getting a threshold level of enjoyment that is lower now than it was when unemployment was less. I dont know when the $3000 came into effect, but it could make sense to raise it again.

[1] By this I mean checking the boxes, qualifications, etc. How easy would it be to just find a job without any extra factors. Ie, hiring a non-skilled worker vs highly-skilled worker. If quality of accepted applicants was very low, then it would be relatively harder to find a job, raising the search cost and screwing up the incentive.

Re:Zappos offers new employees $3000 to quit after a week by mnutt on Tuesday November 16, 2010 @07:52PM (#1912441)
It's also minor compared to the amount of money that companies pay recruiters. If they're paying $15k to place a really good engineer, they can afford to build an extra $3k into the cost of hiring to weed out the few who aren't happy there.
Re:Zappos offers new employees $3000 to quit after a week by joshes on Tuesday November 16, 2010 @07:00PM (#1912287)
I would argue that it's also a smart bet by Zappos in the sense that just such a gesture on the part of management is appreciated by the employees, as well as the public.

And besides, the screening process for new employees probably filters out a decent proportion of the people who actually would be likely to take such a deal.