Re: your first point, it's not a standalone markup language, it's a 1-to-1 replacement for HTML. Markdown is transformed into HTML, but doesn't have to be -- you could PDF it instead, for instance. It's mostly just a way to use structure to eliminate line noise.
- Too much syntax for a pure writing markup languages, compared to Markdown or Wiki syntaxes
- Too little syntax compared to even syntax light languages like JSON or [HT|X]ML (when written with zen coding or a tag matching editor)
It's just kind of awkward. Useful when embedded into rails, but not as a general use markup language.