Re:Affirmation of the Open Source Definition
by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:47PM
(#19101880)
> This is from their FAQ and an example of the OSI explicitly acting like they own "open source"
No, if they were acting like they owned the term, they’d say “No, and we'll take coercive action to stop you if you do.”
What they are actually saying is (in short) “Please don't, experience has shown it causes confusion.”
Re:Affirmation of the Open Source Definition
by LamaOfRuin on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:45PM
(#19101860)
They're not usurping it. They literally created it as a term (and "brand") rather than simply two words. They weren't granted a trademark, so their creation of it has no legal weight, but that doesn't mean they can't claim authority over what it means, and ask that their original intent be respected.
>Can I call my program "Open Source" even if I don't use an approved license?
>Please don't do that. If you call it "Open Source" without using an approved license, you will confuse people. This is not merely a theoretical concern — we have seen this confusion happen in the past, and it's part of the reason we have a formal license approval process. See also our page on license proliferation for why this is a problem.
This is from their FAQ and an example of the OSI explicitly acting like they own "open source". I am fine with proprietary terms being owned and controlled, for example "USB". I am not fine with organizations trying to usurp the language to try to push forward their agenda regardless of their intentions (and generally I approve of the mission of OSI)