News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why existing profanity detection libraries suck and how I... by rebornshellfish on Tuesday February 05, 2019 @11:59AM (#19087134)
There is no sociologically valid use case for a profanity detection library. This is a misuse of technology. Get over your shit.
Re:Why existing profanity detection libraries suck and how I... by ken on Tuesday February 05, 2019 @04:46PM (#19090175)
Is there a "sociologically valid use case" for other software you've seen announced on HN?
Re:Why existing profanity detection libraries suck and how I... by ashleyn on Tuesday February 05, 2019 @12:01PM (#19087152)
Not even making services age-appropriate?
Re:Why existing profanity detection libraries suck and how I... by rebornshellfish on Tuesday February 05, 2019 @12:11PM (#19087256)
Firstly, it won't work because designing a profanity filter can only ever be an eternal game of cat and mouse - there are always going to be new words or ways of r3wr1t1ng the same words. This doesn't take into account the problem of multiple languages.

Secondly, age-appropriate is a far more complex challenge than simply filtering out "bad" words. Anything can be reworded. Families differ in which words they consider acceptable at each age. If you really want to make an online service safe for young children, you probably shouldn't be matching them with unapproved strangers to talk to in any form.

Re:Why existing profanity detection libraries suck and how I... by beobab on Tuesday February 05, 2019 @12:39PM (#19087482)
Are you familiar with the maxim that people behave better if they believe they are being observed?

Would you agree that people would be less likely to “go off on one” if a draft message displayed a “this message could be construed as offensive” warning before they sent it?

Re:Why existing profanity detection libraries suck and how I... by jsjohnst on Tuesday February 05, 2019 @12:52PM (#19087638)
But what defines “offensive”? If you used a “profane” word, I’d likely not even notice. But if you said something negative about me or my family, yes, that’d likely be offensive. Even that isn’t fool proof, a friend saying something negative about me might not be offensive (especially if a truthful statement), but a stranger it would likely always be. There’s so much nuance here that I feel it’s a losing battle.