News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Our Language Affects What We See by jcranmer on Tuesday February 05, 2019 @12:29AM (#19083194)
The real problem with a lot of these studies is that it's difficult to distinguish between a linguistic effect versus a cultural effect--does the language distinguish terms because the linguistic community wishes to do so frequently, or does the distinct terms within the language cause the linguistic community to distinguish the terminology? It is my opinion that, most of the time, if not all, it is the culture driving the language.

I think one interesting example of where the linguistic hints is overridden by the cultural milieu is in the term ski mask. Picture someone wearing a ski mask; what is he about to do: ski down the mountain, or rob a bank? I suspect most people associate the ski mask more readily with a bank robber (particularly the three-hole variant) than a warm weather gear that you might use if the windchill is going to be below 0°F. (I personally use the term balaclava instead of ski mask, though I know there's a large segment of the population who doesn't know what a balaclava is). In that case, the linguistic clue of "ski" is less important than the fact that the main context people see it in is when people are concealing their identities to rob banks in movies.

Re:Our Language Affects What We See by jonahx on Tuesday February 05, 2019 @12:38AM (#19083210)
This quote from the article suggests that mechanism involved is specifically linguistic:

"""

To determine if words were being automatically (and perhaps unconsciously) activated, the researchers added the following twist: they asked their Russian participants to perform a verbal task at the same time as making their perceptual discrimination. This condition eliminated the reaction time advantage of contrasting goluboy and siniy. However, a nonverbal task (a spatial task) could be done at the same time while retaining the goluboy/siniy advantage. The dual task variants indicated that the task of discriminating color patches was aided by silent activation of verbal categories.

"""

Re:Our Language Affects What We See by dorchadas on Tuesday February 05, 2019 @08:02AM (#19084874)
Thank you for posting this. It's always my biggest complaint about Linguistic Relativity... And that so many people believe it simply because it seems like it must be true. Boroditsky (who I associate with the strong push to push it on the public) and her ilk have done a lot of harm, as this does directly impact thinking in terms of things like AAVE, which we've already seen causes transcription errors in court leading to many issues.