News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The infrastructural humiliation of America by nostromo on Monday February 04, 2019 @12:12PM (#19078161)
Americans pay a lot into public infrastructure, but we just get much less for our dollar. (An insane 10x less when talking about urban rail.)

I don't think the American voter is what is broken here. People still believe in infrastructure projects. It's the public sector that has shown they can't be trusted to complete any worthwhile project for a reasonable amount of resources.

The quintessential example of this is urban rail, which is ridiculously expensive in America:

https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2018/01/why-its-so-ex...

https://pedestrianobservations.com/2011/05/16/us-rail-constr...

Re:The infrastructural humiliation of America by lotsofpulp on Monday February 04, 2019 @12:39PM (#19078511)
Voters are the broken piece. They don't vote in local elections, they don't demand accountability, and they like to talk about non issues like weed, abortion, and funding the military industrial complex and being world police.

So few people care about voting that local budgets are subject to the approval of the family and friends of police and firefighters, so we get to pay ever increasing taxes to their unsustainable pensions. Everyone moved to 401k 30 years ago, except for police, fire, and judges. Why is that? Because they all vote, and the rest of the public sits at home watching TV.

Some people don't have enough time, etc, blah blah, but while that is a valid excuse for some, over time, I have realized people are just lazy and they don't want to participate in their communities, they don't want to read the news or go to town meetings even if they have the time. Hence it is the voters fault. It is taken for granted that we have mostly corruption free elections.

Re:The infrastructural humiliation of America by nostromo on Monday February 04, 2019 @12:46PM (#19078595)
I wish local elections were non-partisan for this reason.

I know a lot of folks in far-left cities that think that public sector union benefits are much too generous -- and wish the local government would take crime more seriously -- and wonder if additional tax increases are really in order.

And yet when it's time to vote they choose the candidates on the extreme left... as a rebuke to Trump or something..? even though he has nothing to do with city politics.

Re:The infrastructural humiliation of America by lotsofpulp on Monday February 04, 2019 @12:49PM (#19078632)
Left, right, democrat, republican, it doesn't matter. In local elections, as a candidate, if you're not supporting the police, firefighters, and judges, you're not getting anywhere. Those elections are decided by a couple thousand votes, and every single government employee is going to come in and vote for the candidate that is giving more pay and benefits. Americans also have a weird patriotism fetish anytime police/firefighter issues come up, as benefits do get cut for all other government workers and teachers, police and firefighters are never touched. Obviously, it's important for the rich to have their security guards on their side.

I would love to find a place to live where the government payroll is all cash, no benefits. Pay whatever you have to, six figures and whatnot, it just has to be in cash, so that taxpayers can see and compare the costs accurately.

Pensions and health benefits are nice, since those numbers can be fudged. It gives mayors and city council members plausible deniability and lets them claim they aren't raising taxes or keeping them low, and shove the costs 20 years into the future. Most people aren't going to want to hear about the conflicts of interest on the board of trustees for pension funds or the actuarial consultant being hired by the same people benefiting from the pensions.

Re:The infrastructural humiliation of America by moosey on Monday February 04, 2019 @12:29PM (#19078376)
That's because the public sector doesn't build hardly anything anymore. They pay the private sector to build it.

There are tons of examples of the public sector doing major works throughout the history of the United States. Only now, during a time of incredible distrust in our capability to do public works, does it become expensive/impossible.

Re:The infrastructural humiliation of America by CydeWeys on Monday February 04, 2019 @12:42PM (#19078547)
The private construction sector is simply a lot less honest and more incestuously intertwined with government than it used to be.

To give one example, the Hoover Dam was completed under budget and two years early, and cost well under one billion in today's dollars. There were actually large penalties written into the contract for various stages of the construction taking too long, e.g. $3k per day the diversion tunnels were late, and there was no additional money to be made by fucking up and running over-budget. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hoover_Dam

Contrast with construction projects today, where the goal seems, essentially, to go over budget and over time, because you get paid more that way. The government doesn't hold the companies accountable, and because of this, they purposely run up costs and billable days.

Amazing feats of construction are possible these days with modern technology, way more than what was accomplished with the Hoover Dam, but not when incentives aren't aligned.

There are plenty of other countries where the relationship between private construction companies and the government remains honest, and those citizens thus get a lot more bang for their tax dollar in infrastructure projects.

Re:The infrastructural humiliation of America by njarboe on Monday February 04, 2019 @01:03PM (#19078801)
Cost plus contracts are a huge problem for efficient public funding of projects. Also see NASA'a SLS rocket versus SpaceX's falcon heavy. SpaceX's next generation rocket is going to be so far ahead of the SLS in capabilities and cost it is ridiculous to continue the NASA program. I would not be surprised if the SLS program will even survive the first launch of the BFR. Hopefully they will be able to cancel it at that point and use the funds for funding sending people to mars using SpaceX tech.
Re:The infrastructural humiliation of America by CydeWeys on Monday February 04, 2019 @01:39PM (#19079233)
SLS is a great example because, incredibly, the contractors get paid no matter what. They don't have to achieve goals, meet timelines, or come in on budget. They simply do things and get paid for them.

Contrast with SpaceX, which has to have successful launches in order to survive. They are incentivized to succeed, and so they do. The SLS program has little incentive to succeed, so instead it turns into a game of extracting as much money as possible (which is inimical to succeeding quickly!!!).

Re:The infrastructural humiliation of America by njarboe on Monday February 04, 2019 @04:30PM (#19080824)
" They are incentivized to succeed, and so they do."

Well, they have succeeded so far due to a huge amount of capital and talented people working very hard. I think more importantly is, if a system fails, that it shrinks in power and eventually disappears instead of getting bigger and stronger. A well working free market seems the best way humans have devised to do that so far.

Re:The infrastructural humiliation of America by hoaw on Tuesday February 05, 2019 @08:01AM (#19084868)
That is a selective view of the free market. For any company under pressure to succeed there are others whose expertise is extracting, rather than producing, value. Failed projects, both private and public, are often run by such companies that are successful in what they do, just not in what they deliver.

I think if there is any comprehensive reason why companies like SpaceX, Tesla or e.g. Amazon are successful is because they are vertically integrated. The limited the amount of activity, and responsibility, not under their own control. These days the government is often prevented from doing this, and large companies often want to cut cost in the short term.

These companies have understood that their is less of an information gap these days, so there is little reason to let others take care of you core activities.

Re:The infrastructural humiliation of America by taurath on Monday February 04, 2019 @01:07PM (#19078829)
It feels like the difference between today and projects like the hoover dam is a combination of:

* Private sector grift/contract savviness

* Government corruption or lack of authority to deal with above

* Individual safety prioritized over all else - work stoppages for the most relatively minor of unsafe situations

* Environmental reviews/lawsuits

* Cost of modern materials/manpower

* Lack of will over the past 30 years to fund necessary maintenance

As a total layperson who doesn't work in either construction or government, I'd love to hear whether I'm on the right track here.

Re:The infrastructural humiliation of America by stcredzero on Monday February 04, 2019 @12:39PM (#19078508)
That's because the public sector doesn't build hardly anything anymore. They pay the private sector to build it.

With little in the way of warranties, or so public perception goes. So then the public sector has to pay even more money to get stuff fixed, and contractors have little to no incentive to increase quality. Germany has warranties on roads. Their roads are supposed to be good. Italy isn't as good about warranties on public projects. Their road projects are supposed to be quagmires of corruption.

The US? In the past, the practice had been for 1 year warranties on road projects, but following the example of countries like Germany, Spain, Denmark, Sweden, and Great Britain, federal officials have been trying to extend that out to 5 years for all federally funded road projects. New Mexico had a 20 year warranty on one project.

(EDIT: I did some Googling, and found that some progress had been made, actually. My opinion on this was formed in the 90's, but there's new information now.)

Re:The infrastructural humiliation of America by agumonkey on Monday February 04, 2019 @12:37PM (#19078474)
public/private ventures seems the worst of both world. In France a few big projects of this nature got news coverage, it was a super sad view. Hospital unfit for operations. Millions sunk .. no warranties, nothing.
Re:The infrastructural humiliation of America by paleotrope on Monday February 04, 2019 @01:39PM (#19079219)
More like public/semi-private. Usually private money but the primary contractors have a very close relationship with the public side. Government contracts have been incestuous for a long time.