Caltech is such a school. And its population is largely largely Asian and Jewish, both demographics Harvard has a history of discriminating against.
I am sure Caltech’s administration is considered hopelessly reactionary, but their graduates have the highest number of Nobel prizes per capita. But again, what sort of merit does a Nobel prize prove? Look at the demographics of the winners.
I'm getting this from a chart about halfway down the the following very long article [1]. (Note: I have not read that article. I just searched for info on Jewish enrollment at colleges, and found that chart).
[1] https://www.theamericanconservative.com/articles/the-myth-of...
Harvard's goal, traditionally, has been to [re]produce the ruling class of America, and their admissions criteria are geared accordingly.
- Stanford to produce the ruling class of America, and for
- Harvard to produce the ruling class of Mad Men season 1
(just based on the criteria in the article)
* application score (without race, name, gender, place of origin, etc)
* justice curve (weight score by race, name, gender, place of origin, etc)
The application scoring and justice curves should be carried out by separate impartial groups, with the justice curve preferably applied by a government entity to prevent corruption.
If we truly believe that a student's financial and demographic background have nothing to do with his or her score, then we'd see no statistical evidence of it in achievement tests.
But of course we do. So I think that while your heart is in the right place with respect to fairness, you have overlooked how justice factors in.
Ultimately, we all come from somewhere, and the interactive, dynamic impact of past will impact an individual's future potential.
It's nice to optimize for a static objective problem, like whom to hire or whom to admit. But people are made up from the cumulative and dynamic series of events that began happening long, long before being born. It behooves a stable society to ensure marginalized groups aren't forever left in the cold. This is often expressed with sayings like "losing privilege feels like discrimination."
Think of it this way: in introductory game theory we learn about the Prisoner's Dilemma, where both players are offered a strictly dominating choice -- and so the outcome is entirely predictable. However, what happens when the game framework is repeated indefinitely, without end? The sum of immediate payoffs can be balanced with future payoffs, and different equilibria ("good policy") can be considered (e.g. tit-for-tat). This is not even accounting for further ex-game interaction, which can open more equilibria options.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirmative_action_in_the_Unit...
(I am not claiming that you have to believe that this justifies affirmative action, but you should know that the situation is not as simple as the media talking points would have us believe.)
Would you award me a fields medal, just because I didn't achieve anything since I wasn't taught and guided well regarding mathematics?
We've decided as a nation to outlaw discrimination based on race, gender, sexual orientation, or national origin. We should fucking act like it. If the Asian kid down the street who spent five hours a night studying gets into Harvard and I don't, that's the way it should be.