Is this the argument that the folks in the lawsuit are making? I don’t think so. The argument to me sounds more like “why can’t Harvard make admissions just based just on a test?”
Short answer: There isn’t a standardized test that does a good job of selecting for the “holistic qualities” that certain schools want. Hence the admissions system that most elite schools use.
> On average, alumni give white and Asian American applicants similar ratings, but Harvard staff give whites substantially better reviews than they give Asian Americans.
Maybe extremely high SAT and grades are correlated with poor 'holistic' qualities such as social skills, communication, leadership, creativity, 'round character' (i.e. athleticism, disposition, generosity, musicianship).
I'm not saying they are - I'm saying it wouldn't really surprise me if they were, and then we have to think about it a little bit!
It's a tricky subject no doubt.
If that were so, it would affect members of all ethnicities who had the same high SAT scores and grades equally.
Even if you're right and extremely high SAT and grades are correlated with neurodiversity, physical problems, or rebelliousness, are those qualities colleges should be discriminating against?
And 'athletic' means 'athletic'?
They are unless you have a heap of evidence to suggest they are not.
And yes, Universities should definitely be considering all of those qualities, most of them do to the extent they can.