I think it's fair to say they were generally recruited via social networks. They knew what RenTec was, they knew someone who worked there (maybe an old grad school colleague or a former student), and when they reached out, RenTec already knew who they were. I don't know of anyone who went there who didn't already have a reputation in academia.
So contrary to astazangasta's original claims, they do seem to me to have something of a monopoly on brains. There are other smart people at other firms, but I don't know of any other place that has such a concentration. (Aside from Jeff Dean's office, I suppose. ;)
I don't work in trading anymore, so I'm not talking my book here. Trading is zero-sum at a transactional level, but has knock on benefits beyond profit and loss:
-Making it easy for companies to raise capital through IPOs or offerings (without a robust secondary market for securities, people will be less likely to invest)
-In commodities: Letting businesses bear the risks they want and insure against the ones that aren't their core business
-Liquid markets let real people trade in and out of investments without friction at fair prices
-Providing accurate price signals to other businesses and the broader economy
So I don't think I was saving the whales, but I don't think it was wasteful, either.
Also, as a mildly clever OCD math guy who's semi-good at writing fast C++ code, I don't think I would have been curing cancer anyway.
ETA: At least in the case of HFT, if you accept that markets need intermediaries of some sort, it seems more efficient to have a few dozen tech/math guys do the same job thousands of guys in mesh vests were doing years ago, and cheaper.
I mean there are computational cancer models that need to be written and optimized.
But character references aside, the claim that Medallion is skimming the other funds just doesn't add up: Medallion is at capacity and has been for at least a decade. It's been producing at least $3B / year in profits during that time, and that's redistributed to RenTec employees as cashflow, either as bonus (from their infamous 5/45) or as profits returned to the Medallion investors. So, we're talking about minimum $30B spun out in cash over the past decade. That's basically the total AUM of their other funds.
If you have your ear to the ground you can find many proprietary trading firms which have similar or even superior returns. It's much harder to find a fund deploying similar strategies at the same capacity.
As a corollary, every single new hire at the firm is expensive in more than the traditional ways. They only have so much room in Medallion, and so they tend to be both extremely secretive and extremely protective when hiring. They've lessened up on that somewhat recently, but it's still there.