HSR for passenger already requires dedicated tracks. Mixing 220mph trains and 75mph trains tends not to work very well. (Not to mention the curvature requirements precluding a lot of existing right of way).
The real problem is the lack of demand for passenger traffic. HSR ridership falls off a cliff around 2-3 hours; in practice, you're limited to looking at city pairs within around 500-700mi max, ideally all in a nice line, and outside the NEC, there's just too few of these pairs.
Re:The IPO of Virgin Trains U.S.A.
by bobthepanda on Saturday February 02, 2019 @03:37PM
(#19065538)
The pairs are more numerous than you'd think. Put 560 mile circles around Atlanta, New York, Chicago, Dallas, Los Angeles, and Seattle and you basically cover most major metro areas in the US.
A single pair by itself is not enough to make the investment cost worth it. (This is the Midwest conundrum--there's actually a decent selection of third tier cities, but no three of them are close to collinear).
Re:The IPO of Virgin Trains U.S.A.
by bobthepanda on Sunday February 03, 2019 @01:06PM
(#19071133)
Three of them can be collinear if you consider Chicago a viable third city (e.g. Indianapolis - Milwaukee).
Some city pairs are kind of isolated (St Louis, Kansas City).
Some have decently sized cities that you can connect in a linear fashion (Chicago > Indianapolis > Louisville > Nashville)
And some you can serve in a somewhat roundabout fashion while still being time competitive (Chicago > Indianapolis > Cincinnati > Columbus > Pittsburgh).
It's better just to build more capacity and reserve it for passenger.