News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The IPO of Virgin Trains U.S.A. by swiley on Friday February 01, 2019 @04:31PM (#19058852)
Wow I didn’t know about the drug planting. I just assumed consenting sucked but was the optimal thing to do.
Re:The IPO of Virgin Trains U.S.A. by jMyles on Friday February 01, 2019 @04:36PM (#19058896)
What's the advantage of consenting? It seems purely disadvantageous for the passenger. It's not like you consent and they suddenly go away. I presume that if you consent, they proceed to search all your stuff.

Even if they don't steal or plant anything, it's a huge invasion of privacy and, if you have any delicate items, a risk that they'll be damaged.

Re:The IPO of Virgin Trains U.S.A. by dsfyu404ed on Friday February 01, 2019 @04:42PM (#19058968)
There is no advantage to consenting to a search or talking to police. Ever.
Re:The IPO of Virgin Trains U.S.A. by wahern on Friday February 01, 2019 @07:24PM (#19060092)
Refusing to speak to the police or otherwise being evasive is not the same as exercising your rights. Your behavior prior to requesting an attorney can be used against you--"he was acting suspicious by not giving me direct answers". But you can't request an attorney unless you've been detained, which they won't do.

I don't think there's any substitute for (a) being polite ("Yes, sir. No, sir.") and (b) being aware of the context. Obviously you should never consent to a search or even give the impression that you're consenting. But literally not talking to the police is not really possible, so there's no avoiding keeping your wits about you so you can act in the most appropriate way possible.

Pulling out your camera is a pretty ballsy move that could escalate things, but I wasn't there so can't judge. But if there were witnesses watching such as other passengers or, especially, a conductor, I wouldn't risk it. I'd just ask for the witnesses' contact information afterward. An irate cop could always snatch your phone away; it's much harder to intimidate a witness, and anyone inclined to do that probably wouldn't think twice about taking your phone or doing something worse later, anyhow. Ultimately you're pretty much helpless, so you have to optimize for the [more likely case] of the cops being mostly honest. They're unfortunately trained to intimidate (we've militarized our civilian police forces), so just because they're acting like assholes doesn't mean they're actually assholes.

Re:The IPO of Virgin Trains U.S.A. by ghthor on Friday February 01, 2019 @11:07PM (#19060967)
Thanks you for this empathic and balanced response. I'm quite tired of the narrative that the police are all assholes, as the ones that do act like assholes I've met has mostly been because they've been screwed by someone treating them like shit. Or as you've said, from the insanity that has been the training we've been giving them.
Re:The IPO of Virgin Trains U.S.A. by jjoonathan on Friday February 01, 2019 @04:53PM (#19059081)
Pissing off someone with considerable discretionary power to make your life miserable has no disadvantages, ever?
Re:The IPO of Virgin Trains U.S.A. by jMyles on Friday February 01, 2019 @05:10PM (#19059237)
There may be cases where appeasing someone with discretionary power (real or perceived) leads to a better outcome, but consenting to an otherwise illegal search doesn't seem like it's possibly one of them to me.

Am I missing something?

Re:The IPO of Virgin Trains U.S.A. by sjjshzvuiajhz on Friday February 01, 2019 @08:59PM (#19060516)
Well, if we’re talking about corrupt cops who will plant drugs, might they also lie about you consenting to the search? Maybe you’re better off doing whatever it takes to make them like you, so they are less likely make you the person they plant drugs on?

I don’t know what the right answer is, it seems like a tough call. I’m skeptical of people who confidently say “consenting is never the right answer”.

Re:The IPO of Virgin Trains U.S.A. by jMyles on Friday February 01, 2019 @10:03PM (#19060749)
Well, you also need to record the conversation. I think that goes without saying.
Re:The IPO of Virgin Trains U.S.A. by toomuchtodo on Friday February 01, 2019 @04:55PM (#19059105)
"Regent Law Professor James Duane gives viewers startling reasons why they should always exercise their 5th Amendment rights when questioned by government officials."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE

Mandatory viewing IMHO.

Re:The IPO of Virgin Trains U.S.A. by est31 on Friday February 01, 2019 @06:04PM (#19059644)
That's an awesome video. The guy talks a bit fast, but very great video that shows how much can go wrong. He especially makes the "I am innocent, why should I not talk to police" case be moot. Indeed, being innocent is the best defense there is against being convicted of a crime, but claiming to be innocent right at the beginning might not help your case.
Re:The IPO of Virgin Trains U.S.A. by mikeash on Friday February 01, 2019 @05:30PM (#19059400)
If they’re asking for consent to perform a search then they are already using their discretionary power in an attempt to make your life miserable. Giving your consent isn’t going to help.
Re:The IPO of Virgin Trains U.S.A. by mikeash on Friday February 01, 2019 @05:29PM (#19059389)
Remember, if they have probable cause to perform a search then they won’t ask you. If they ask you it’s because their alternative is to go away.