Obviously, my pocket-sized rule of thumb isn't designed for people who earn $100+K per year. Those people can afford accountants. Likewise, people for whom adjusted gross income is a necessarily complex calculation involving the phase of the moon can probably also afford accountants; if not, they need a simpler or more profitable financial plan.
Hiring an accountant isn't a particularly difficult thing to do. They're on every street corner. In the month of March, you'll find people dressed in costumes standing at the side of the road, advertising them. [1] And even the robot tax accountant built into Quicken Online was pretty good, in my limited experience. Would Quicken Online have caught the OP's FICA problem? I don't know, but quite possibly. I've never tried to declare substantial quantities of non-1099, non-W2 income in Quicken before, but you'd think it would at least pop up an ominous dialog box.
---
[1] A friend of mine had this job once.
Actually, this isn't true; the Social Security portion of FICA (which is most of it) is only paid on the first $106k of your gross income (in 2010). Additionally, the word "income" in your sentence reveals some very complex questions about the differences between gross revenue, gross income, modified adjusted gross income, etc. The "income" against which you pay taxes can vary greatly from the actual cash coming into your bank account, thanks to a variety of deductions and credits. I own real estate that produces positive cashflow but I take a "loss" on it every year according to the IRS, offsetting some of my other income.
Your best advice here is to hire an accountant :)