FIDO is the way forward, but having run into Microsoft's hapless first attempt (since they managed to get it to not work in anything except Edge on specific builds of Windows they also made it optional, so it actually can't make your security better. Brilliant) I have less confidence it'll ever be useful to the ordinary person... Still, it does protect my Google account.
That makes phone based TOTP the most secure second factor that is pretty much universally accessible to lay users (i.e. not buying a dedicated second factor device, and most people have smartphones).
FIDO U2F isn't quite there yet in terms of universal support, but its design is definitely promising from a usability perspective. It's one technology I'm willing to hold my breath for.
The best implementations I see are the ones that allow both phone authenticator apps for the people who don't want to carry a keyfob around or need to log in via their phones, and U2F for people who want their physical factor separate from their phone.