If it was clearly a premium option that you paid good money for, the bank or brokerage could have a smart, well trained person handle this. Charge me more than $100, if that what it takes. I think if you eliminate people that don't live in your legal jurisdiction from defrauding you and make them show up somewhere in person (Russian hacker, Nigerian scams) the likelihood of the fraud happening goes down by 3-4 orders of magnitude.
The magic word is Medallion Signature Guarantee and the mechanism is, basically, "Bank of America is satisfied that we were talking to Bob when we affixed this medallion on this paper and if we were wrong we're good for $500k."
The most likely place one is likely to run into this (assuming a typical-for-HN sort of life plan) is if you accumulate a substantial amount of money in your retirement account and then try to transfer it to a different brokerage.
Overall, I don't know if there is a perfect solution. Perhaps for banks we should pee-in-a-cup DNA test in addition to other tests. For a porn site we can do a poor mans email reset.