Re:The irony of the US economy: no jobs and no one to hire
by rbranson on Sunday November 14, 2010 @12:48PM
(#1903658)
Disclaimer: zerohedge is a bunch of hysterical Austrian economist nutcases.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The irony of the US economy: no jobs and no one to hire
by SkyMarshal on Sunday November 14, 2010 @01:06PM
(#1903708)
Ad hominem, try again.
Re:The irony of the US economy: no jobs and no one to hire
by johnny22 on Sunday November 14, 2010 @01:52PM
(#1903823)
Perhaps it's just bias, but i have real trouble taking any advice or getting news from somebody who goes by the pseudonym "Tyler Durden", or anybody who ends up getting published by said person.
Re:The irony of the US economy: no jobs and no one to hire
by SkyMarshal on Sunday November 14, 2010 @08:06PM
(#1904791)
Agreed it's a bit silly, but it's still worth training yourself to look past that and evaluate the argument independently of its presentation and other irrevelant context.
It's hard, and I use the word 'train' intentionally b/c it requires discipline and constant attention. But I've uncovered gems of understanding over the years from doing that, that I wouldn't have otherwise, some which confirmed my worldview, and others which refuted it or expanded it.
Some people are brilliantly insightful, but just awful at communicating and presenting their understanding.
Re:The irony of the US economy: no jobs and no one to hire
by natrius on Sunday November 14, 2010 @06:05PM
(#1904489)
Pointing out biases isn't an ad hominem argument. Arguing that someone is wrong because of their biases is an ad hominem.
Re:The irony of the US economy: no jobs and no one to hire
by SkyMarshal on Sunday November 14, 2010 @08:00PM
(#1904777)
'Hysterical' + 'nutcases' = ad hominem. Personal attack intended to discredit the argument. I wasn't referring to the 'Austrian' part. If someone thinks Austrian economics is wrong or a flawed framework for understanding some phenomena or topic, just explain why.
Also, I'm not sure that their Austrian favoritism has any bearing on this particular claim. Arguing that the BLS is intentionally fudging and later revising data to mitigate its effect on the markets seems economic-creed-agnostic.